Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
If you're looking for originality and a thriller suspense filled drama that keeps you on the edge of the seat, W is one of the few that will satisfy that hunger. This drama filled with unpredictability and full of anticipation has its reason why it became one of the highly anticipated dramas of 2016. This drama will also hit a soft spot for the majority of the audience who perhaps had a thing for fictional characters- and I'm no exception.Story
Oh man, I was hooked right from the start- the plotline moved incredible fast during the first few episodes which resulted in me binge-watching all 16 episodes in 2 days, without any regrets. The summary sounds simple, a webtoon character comes to life and struggles to live- however it's more than that. It follows Kang Chul and his hardships and struggles to live while everyone is out to kill him, and you can't help but emphasize with him as this character just simply wants to live as a human, and who has a right to take that from him?
The Good
What really made this drama successful is Lee Joon Suk and his incredible portrayal of his character really brought this story to life, however like all dramas, there always something that could be done better. Aside from Kang Chul, Yeon Joo's father is the only other person I found incredible- his portrayal of a father turned psycho over his creation coming to life was incredibly realistic- who wouldnt freak out if the character you drew was out to kill you?
The music was wonderful- the music fit the mood of this piece quite well and the instrumentals were the best, I already downloaded some of the OSTs which already tells that I liked it.
The Bad
The female lead Yeon Joo was amazing, don't get me wrong since I didn't mention her in the good- however she had so much potential at first. she's a doctor for goodness sake but it seemed like with every accident that happens, she just somehow never makes it on time to save the day and although she is a strong confident woman, when romance kicks in- she is reduced to a love-induced mess.
Romance. Did I expect romance? Of course, with almost every drama- there is always at least a bit of romance, which is totally fine. It was adorable in the beginning, how an enigmatic man is curious about this secretive woman full of mysteries- however nearing the end, it makes you question, just why on earth did they fall in love with each other? Their romance was sadly very spurious, it was just two leading roles acting out scripted lines and I did not feel any spark between the two which was quite disappointing. It made me question what made the two fall in love with each other? It only seemed like they got together because Kang Chul deemed her as the key to his life to figure out the ultimate truth.
Not to mention, the side characters were beyond regrettable as they had so much potential to be more than just someone to fill out Kang Chul's life and perhaps further the plot slightly.. the side characters didn't have much.....character (haha) at all as they existed just so Kang Chul wouldn't be reduced to a crazy lonely billionaire. I was looking forward to his sidekicks and how they would help him act out his revenge on the killer or save him- but literally, they were almost never there when he was in trouble. It was literally just Kang Chul + Yeon Joo versus the villians.
Plot Holes- this story is filled with confusion, especially at times. Overall, there may be illogical moments but it's still doable, however the ending did not make sense to me- as i felt like the writer only made the ending that way because people wanted it. I know its confusing but I can't really explain much without giving away spoilers. Some things may be illogical but it ties up in the end... well most of them, and some other things just downright do not make sense.
You must be wondering why I'm giving this drama such a high score with all these paragraphs of what I didn't like- but thats because this drama is exceptional despite its problems. These little plot-holes are insignificant when you look at the bigger picture as you're too overwhelmed with what truly matters- the story line.
To conclude, I highly recommend you to watch it as its one of a kind, however don't expect it to be the best dramas ever- but I sincerely enjoyed every moment
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
I've never watched any drama, even foreign series having the same story line. And every episode gives your a different twist and excitement.
The actors are all amazing as well, they're really an effective actors.
this drama deserves to be extended more than just 16 episodes.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
It was the best in everything
I don't know what to say but I'm gonna bless the one who wrote it because I think he's a genius. I mean every episode came with something new, innovative.Now to talk about the actors they are also very very good and had a best chemistry.
I think I watched every ep with curiosity,happiness and sometimes sadness too but this doesn't matters because, aah,to say in four words: THE BEST DRAMA EVER WITH THE BEST PLOT,BEST CHARACTERS,THE BEST PRODUCER,THE BEST DIRECTOR .......I think I need more than four words to describe it and to describe what I feel. 1000000000 stars for this beautiful drama
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
I love this drama! Particularly since the concept is great – in and out of the 2 worlds and the readers of the manhwa actually see how the characters deal with the fact that they are in manhwa and how they come to term with it, how Yeon Joo’s dad gave his face to the killer and the consequences of it and how they tried to end it (you literally can read from the manhwa how Kang Cheol discussed the ending lol). Its pretty cool if you think about it. How exciting to read that kind of manhwa in real life. So I ended up really like it a lot. I want to be entertained while watching a drama so I ended up enjoying lots of the plot twists – it is enjoyable when you can’t predict it. And I understand all the rules and concepts of the manhwa world so I pretty much understand why this and that happened so I didn’t end up hating the plots.But it seemed many people didn’t understand the concept of the W world since many keep asking if the world keep spinning when Kang Cheol is no longer there. The writer pretty much explained everything in the drama. The W world is just another world that moves on its own. Yeon Joo’s dad only control the lives of the main characters of the manhwa through the tablet and his drawings. But despite that, these manhwa characters can control their own destiny as Kang Cheol managed to save himself many times despite the countless of times Yeon Joo’s dad tried to kill him. So with or without Kang Cheol in the W world, the world still exist and everyone is living there normally. The concept is that the W world is just another world in another dimension. It moves on its on with or without Kang Cheol.
Many were also confused on what happened to Yeon Joo’s dad. He died/disappear as Kang Cheol is the one who survive the end. It is the last chapter, so one of them needs to die for the manhwa to end. He supposed to kill Kang Cheol to survive (noticed how the Dad’s hands stop disappearing when Kang Cheol was shot) but since he killed the congressman and let Kang Cheol survive, he will cease to exist because of that. Why one of them need to die? It got to do with the fact that they keep disappearing when they are not doing anything – it indicates they need to end it properly for one of them to survive.
Its understandable why people lost interest in the second half of the drama especially when it got confusing. But this drama still score high on my list for its creativity and pace alone. Not many Kdramas as unpredictable as this so I enjoyed this one a looooot. And I finally see the fuss on Lee Jong Suk. He is an amazing actor without a doubt. The revelation scene between Yeon Joo’s dad and him is very memorable. How his expressions change from sad, disappointed to angry is just amazing.
I thought the scene when Kang Cheol was waiting at the Bus Stop was particularly heart wrenching – how he kept calling Yeon Joo since he knew he’s running out of time and when Yeon Joo come back to the real world before reaching him was brilliant as well.
As someone who have been watching Kdramas for more than a decade, I’m really tired of watching sad or plateau endings in Kdramas. I’m glad that it is not the case for this one. Its a happy ending and a deserved one at that considering the main character had suffered so much – being shot, stabbed, beaten, prisoned, family killed, realization that he is just a character and etc… He’s just very pitiful and I’m glad they give Kang Cheol a happy ending. :D
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Be prepared for the most satisfying and well balanced K drama on your plate!
So this is the first K drama I have ever watched and...I just love it! The plot hooked me in right from the beginning. Not gonna lie I was not a fan of K dramas, it was actually my bestie who suggested this and I found the topic interesting so I decided to give it a go. And it was amazing. It completely satisfied me.The plot was just...wow. I loved the idea, and there was always something happening on screen that made it impossible to stop watch. For the people who rated this below 8/10, I will never understand you. Of course there were cute, cosy and adorable moments with just the right pinch of humour and comedy in the midst of all seriousness. It was a very balanced blend of an interesting plot with a bit of humour and romance. There are also scenes that make you tear up, or maybe just me cause I'm really sensitive...But still!
And the acting was also really good as well! This being the first K drama I have ever watched, and not knowing any actors or actresses I knew that Han Hyo Joo and Lee Jong Suk, were definitely one of my favourite actors.
Okay, not gonna lie I forgot all about the music so I listened to it again and I wouldn't say that I liked it but I wouldn't say that I hated it. Altogether the music was alright but I didn't fall in love with it like I normally do.
The re - watch value is high because I re - watched the whole thing like 5 times again as soon as I finished it. And then I got tired of watching it over and over again, but now I'm back to it again.
So overall this is an amazing drama, the only reason I didn't give it 10/10 is because it was kinda sad, and bits where they were trying to create suspense were actually sometimes (very rarely) confusing. But all in all I would completely recommend this.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Like a tire with a slow leak
This drama started strong. Then somewhere in the middle third it began slowly deflating, until by the end it was completely flat.The premise of a fictional character with such a strong will to live that he begins to influence the writer and eventually more is intriguing. Pulling people from the real world to the world of the manhwa through the tablet was clever, and it was made clear that there had to be certain circumstances to switch universes - until suddenly that no longer seemed to be necessary. No longer moments of suspense or excitement where a "to be continued..." cliffhanger would normally occur, but instead characters were coming and going as they pleased without a reasonable explanation - except for when it would be inconvenient to the plot for it to happen. The same sort of inconsistent changing of boundaries also occurred with who could traverse between universes, characters creating themselves or being completely outside of anything entered on the tablet and the originally set idea that when the main character is doing something time doesn't flow normally for the rest. It was frustrating to see such a novel idea turned into an empty shell after an exciting beginning.
There were moments when the acting was the only reason to keep watching, but unfortunately the acting also became worse as they show progressed; I believe the actors also realized the story was completely derailed beyond hope by the midway point and they just wanted it to be over. The leads were well-cast, and Han Hyo Joo and Lee Jong Suk both have electrifying smiles. Unfortunately they were unable to overcome the plot holes and absurdities, but this was not through any fault of their own.
Finally, I'd be amiss if I ignored the ending. There was once again a sudden arbitrary rule placed so there had to be a happy ending and a sad ending. It didn't make sense with anything that had occurred so far, and Kang Chul's reappearance in the real world when the link had been severed felt like nothing more than the writer trying to force a fairy tale ending with no explanation. Really, the best way I can sum up both the happy and sad endings - my eyes stayed completely dry for both.
끝
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
W (2016)
A creative premise that was well thought-out and has aged relatively well in terms of production and presentation. The show blurred the lines of reality, blurred the lines of good and evil, and ventured into concepts that were waiting to be explored.BUT.
Sometime after establishing the, uh, logistics and rules of the universe the show decides to flip the script and break all of its own conventions. At first it was just minor details that were occasionally to mildly annoying. Then you notice inconsistencies, Then the story develops too many ideas without knowing how to finish them. The twists and turns throughout and effort to commit to things that are not usually done/done well in the k-drama world does deserve credit.
But effort isn't everything. You still have to know how to execute and have an idea of how things should play out. Unfortunately, the show began to lose itself in its own proverbial plot. And that friends, is not exactly a W.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Unique Story, But Beware Plotholes
Before writing this review, I watched this drama through twice, back-to-back. The first time was a full watch, from start to finish, with not a single second skipped, while the second time was a speed watch, where I skipped over scenes and plots that didn't especially hold my interest the first time around and paid more attention to the main storyline/lead couple.I want to start this review off by saying... Overall, I definitely enjoyed this drama. It gets points right off the bat for being a unique if not incredibly ambitious drama. W tells the story of Oh Yeon-joo (played by Han Hyo-joo), a (somewhat struggling/untalented) cardiothoracic surgeon who happens to be the daughter of Korea's most beloved webtoon/manhwa artist, Oh Seong-moo (played by a scene-stealing Kim Eui-sung). Seong-moo's creation-- W-- is lead by main character, Kang Chul (played by Lee Jong-suk), an extremely successful and wealthy, self-made, former gold medal Olympian in shooting, who's family was murdered by an unknown assailant ten years before the start of the series in the comic book's version of Seoul.
After Oh Seong-moo's wife leaves him, taking Oh Yeon-joo with her, the artist struggles with alcohol abuse and suicidal, self-destructive ideations. He uses his creation, Kang Chul, to act out his own cowardly desires and self-destruction, but the strong-willed main character who fights for righteousness refuses to go down without a fight and accept the death his artist chose for him. From that point on, Chul continues to fight against Seong-moo's intentions and drawings, increasingly derailing Seong-moo's attempts to sabotage his creation, who he grows more and more frightened of with each defeat. When Seong-moo makes one last, desperate attempt to destroy Chul, both he and his daughter are pulled into the world of the webtoon, and their immediate actions upon landing there will have deep repercussions for the webtoon, the characters within it, and the real world they are from.
When I say this story was ambitious, I mean it. There are essentially two casts, the cast of the webtoon which consist of Chul's nearest and dearest, the villains that pursue him, thugs he regularly faces, and a slew of background characters, and then the cast of the real world, populated by the apprentice artists in Seong-moo's studio and the other doctors and residents at Yeon-joo's hospital. Chul's version of Seoul is filled with penthouse apartments, high-end boutiques, and sports cars. Yeon-joo's version of Seoul is filled with overworked doctors surviving off naps in a cramped break room and manic, demanding superiors. Chul's world is filled with the excitement, adventure, and thrill that made W so popular with readers, while Yeon-joo's world would be boring if not for the webtoon beginning to bleed into it. I think the series does a good job of differentiating these worlds, even though we're repeatedly reminded that not only are they taking place in the same city, but many of the buildings appear in both (just with different names).
There are a lot of special effects throughout the series that are in and of themselves kind of a character in the series. Production didn't seem to spare any expense when it came to them. We see cartoon panels draw themselves, characters and items be drawn into existence out of nothing, and characters appearing and disappearing as they fulfill their purpose or fight against it. Considering the world they were creating, the effects are sound and impressive.
That said, the series may have been a little -too- ambitious with the story they were trying to tell. The rules for the universe seem to change on a dime and be inconsistent. Chul seems to explain these away as "variables," but it's mostly just inconsistent story-telling. Rules exist for something when convenient, and when they get in the way of advancing the plot, they're suddenly abolished for no apparent reason. For example, we learn early in the series that Chul (and other key characters in the series) are able to pull Yeon-joo into the webtoon just by thinking about her. The magic drawing tablet (a character unto itself and the most inconsistent of them all) doesn't have to be on or functioning for this to happen, the character just needs to need/want her for it to happen, yet at the end of the series, Yeon-joo is stuck outside of the webtoon for a year of webtoon time because.... Honestly, I have no idea, and I watched it twice. It seems like they try to tie it to the tablet being turned on again, but we've seen her travel without the tablet functioning/being on before, so why? It was just what they needed for the story, I guess. Those inconsistencies and plot holes are frustrating, to say the least.
Character-wise-- and I really hate to say this-- I think Kang Chul is the weak spot. Let me immediately clarify by saying this is in no way a condemnation of Lee Jong-suk's performance! He is electric on the screen. Eyes are drawn to him and his charm is undeniable. The disconnect is on the writers/material he was given. Kang Chul is just-- to me-- a bit unlikeable and inconsistent. Chul's relationship with Yeon-joo feels decidedly imbalanced, especially their first go round, but also still in their second. Yeon-joo wears her heart on her sleeve for Chul, the ideal man she dreamed up as a child, but the affection often feels one-sided to the point more than once I experienced a kind of secondhand embarrassment on Yeon-joo's behalf. By the end of the series, I can accept them as a couple, but even then, to a certain degree it feels like Chul has just accepted Yeon-joo as his fate (even though he insists he chose her).
The best acting in the series comes from Han Sang-hoon, who plays the double role of both Yeon-joo's father and the murderer of Chul's family and his greatest enemy. He swings back and forth between the roles in a moment's notice, invoking fear then sympathy, followed by psychopathy and patheticness in dizzying succession. If you're a crier like me, Han Sang-hoon will pull a few tears from you in the finale, I can promise you that. Lee Jong-suk and Han Hyo-joo each perform their roles well as the leads. Lee Si-eon as Oh Seong-moo's apprentice Park Soo-bong and Kang Ki-young (who I adore!) as Yeon-joo's fellow resident surgeon Kang Suk-beom are great in their supporting roles. I never really warmed up to Jung Yoo-jin as Yoon So-hee, Chul's assistant and expected love interest and Lee Tae-hwan as Seo Do-yoon, Chul's bodyguard and best friend. They both felt a little one-dimensional and one-note as characters, but maybe that was intentional since they're supposed to be manhwa characters... I don't know. Either way, the characters around Yeon-joo definitely trumped those around Chul.
The music in W is, in a word, fantastic. I bought the OST right away after finishing the series a first time. I'm a little reluctant to admit that Jung Joon-young's performance of "Where Are U" is a standout given who he turned out to be, but the song really is great. The hip-hop track, "In the Illusion" by Basick, featuring Inkii is an unexpected gem. "Without You" by N of VIXX and Yeoeun of Melody Day is great, as is "Falling" by Jo Hyun-ah of Urban Zakapa and "Please Say Something, Even Though It's a Lie" by Park Bo-ram. I'm a big fan of KCM, but his song "Remember" is the weak spot of the OST.
I would definitely say W has rewatch potential. I caught things on the second go-round that I had missed the first time, so I'd even go so far as to say repeated watching would be a good idea. I think it's especially true since there is a lot of complexity to the plot, and it was overall easier to follow and understand in my rewatch than it was in my initial viewing. I've seen it twice now and I'll probably give it a third watch at some point in the future. It hits a lot of good notes; there's action, adventure, love, and sacrifice. It's not a drama to have playing while you're doing other things; it requires focus to follow, but it was more fun the second time around, so I would definitely encourage rewatches.
Overall, I enjoyed it. Is it perfect? No. Are the characters and writing perfect? No. Is the world-building perfect? No. But is it enjoyable? Yes. Do I regret watching it? Absolutely not. So give it a chance. It's a pretty good way to spend sixteen hours.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Story:-
The good
Like I've said this korean drama has an intriguing plot which is the main factor which convinced me to watch this drama. I seriously love how the first episode made me hooked into this drama and as I watched, it exceeded my expectations on how beautifully written this drama is. The mystery in this drama is really thrilling and unpredictable. Every event seem to link with one another just like stars in the sky who seem to not be related but once connected, creates an image.
The bad
The first half of the drama was so awesome that the excitements seems to dissipate when it comes to the story development of the second half of the drama. Not saying that it became a terrible drama after the second half, but it is totally lacking the intensity and rationality. It seemed like the story is being rushed and too many twists have been put into it. Instead of enjoying the drama due to the abundance of plot twists, it made the viewer feel stressed.
Character Development:-
The characters were one of my favourite aspects of this drama especially Kang Chul. However I felt that his character actually fell flat after that. As for Oh Yeon Joo, sometimes I do like her character but sometimes I still don't understand how she fell in love with Kang Chul (same to Kang Chul's side) Probably they should include some narrations to explain their thoughts and feelings. Oh Seong Moo's character was well done for a villain. Sometimes, I find it hard to actually connect and feel the characters deeply because their actions are confusing (first half was good, second half was just meh)
Overall:-
This drama started off as a full 10 for me but I took 0.5 marks out of it because the story went downhill. I still can't forget the awesomeness of the drama in the beginning so I didn't give this drama a low score. I felt that the events of the story could be explained more properly and an extension of the drama to 20 episodes would be ideal to interpret them and to tie loose ends. The acting is pretty good and the casts did a good job in portraying their characters although there might be room for improvement for some of the supporting casts.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
To the doubters:I can see there are many reviews complimenting this drama, but also plenty who are more critical. Personally I really liked this drama, but when I read the reviews who criticize the drama, I can't disagree entirely with them. However, the issues they mention, I have not been bothered by myself/have not noticed and even looking back I often feel it's not that bad. So my advise to doubters is to give the drama a try and if you're not into it after 2 or maybe 3 episodes? Maybe it's not for you. Because of its fast pace, you'll know soon enough if it is your kind of drama or not. :)
Let me just add - I'm glad I avoided the hype and waited with watching until the hype had simmered down a bit. I think if I had allowed myself to get hyped up about this drama, I might have ended up being disappointed. But having started watching it with the idea of it being simply a 'good' drama, rather than an amazing one, I feel like I have been allowed to enjoy it all the more.
Story
The first thing I have to compliment this drama's story on is the pacing. There is not a dull moment for even a second. Things progress/happen all the time, pulling you through the episodes easily. During the first episode I forgot all about my cup of tea for a full hour. I didn't notice time passing at all because I didn't feel like it was an hour!
There are a lot of plot twists. Just when you think you have something figured out, you will learn a new bit of detail that throws it all around. I have been told this drama could be confusing at times, but personally I didn't experience any confusion at all. Maybe because I binge watched it?
I'm someone who usually gets really irritated by plot-holes or unrealistic situations/reactions. I've seen reviews about there being plot-holes and non-realism, but I personally didn't notice or experience annoyance over things.
Also; I really enjoyed to see the comparison between the real world and the comic world. How time passes by. The point of view of characters. And because I can't mention it elsewhere: I LOVE(!!) the artwork you see. It was so gorgeous, I couldn't get enough of it. Luckily, you get to see it often.
My only criticism here would be that I feel the ending had a few minor things in which I felt it was lacking. Let me start by saying I love the ending. It's an open ending and depending on your own experience of the drama, you could consider it to be a happy ending or a sad happy ending. For me, it was the latter. I remember Lee Jong Suk saying that he feels a sad ending would have been for the best. And though I agree with his vision on it, emotionally I'm glad that the writer didn't go for a sad ending entirely. That aside - I felt it was a bit lacking because I have a few question marks left about a few supporting roles. I wish I could have seen those wrapped up a little better. For spoiler's sake, I won't mention names. However - I'm glad the drama was only 16 episodes.
In conclusion - I love the pacing. I love the plot twists. I love the originality of the plot. I love the art.
But I do have a few small mentions on the side.
Acting/Cast
Like many - I'm a fan of Lee Jong Suk. And I don't think I have to get in-depth in how great his acting was. How good he brought the emotions in his eyes and all that. He was a dream to be watching. Compliments aside - I do have a bit of criticism here. I don't think it's Lee Jong Suk's fault, but rather the character he played. Though I loved him and his character to death and he had me squeal and cry regularly, I did feel like I could have been more emotionally attached. So I'm a bit disappointed I didn't feel stronger? Having read through some more critical reviews, I think maybe it's because there isn't much development within the character. Looking back, I don't feel Kang Chul has changed much between episode 1 and 16.
The same goes for Han Hyo Joo who plays Oh Yeon Joo. I didn't know her, but grew to love her instantly. I have nothing but love for her acting. But as much as I loved it, here as well - I felt there was still something lacking. And I guess it's the character development that is to blame here yet again. Very little difference between episode 1 and 16.
But don't let this scare you! The story and acting really still pulled me in a lot. And as I mentioned - I /did/ squeal and cry and laugh. It's just that when I compare it to other Drama's I rated 10/10; I feel like I didn't feel as overwhelming emotion, making me unable to rate it 10/10 as well.
Also - The chemistry between the leads is amazing. I had seen it in behind the scenes, but I definitely also saw it on screen. They were so adorable at the best of times. I like how there was a lot of romance in between the action.
The rest of the casting did very well on their characters as well. I have nothing but good things to say about them really, so I won't go in-depth about them.
Music
Perfect.
Often, I don't really notice the background music during drama's, so when a song stands out and catches my attention, it's often a sign that it's really good. I had that feeling during this drama. Often the music would catch my attention, making me want to look it up.
I shouldn't have looked it up mid-watch though. Because I found out who sang one of the songs.. I started paying more attention to the song when it played than the scene, making me lose my emotional connection. |D But this was my own fault, haha.
In short - The music was just perfect and I think it fit the drama very well.
Rewatch Value
High. Definitely. If not for the story, then for the beautiful work of art and acting.
Personally, I would wait a while until I'd have forgotten a few things, so I would be able to experience the plot twists again.
Conclusion:
After rating everything separately and thinking things through, the end-score is a 9.5/10. I think I'm content about this, because I would have loved to give it a 10, but felt like that wouldn't be true to my personal experience. There are a few minor things that just don't make it perfect. And scoring it a 9 would have felt like I would be rating it too low, especially when I compare it to other drama's I've rated 9/10.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
This Kdrama is definitely one for the books. If you want a plot that is really new, and different from all the dramas out there, this one is for you. Never have I seen a storyline this unique. I loved the story of Kang Chul and Oh Yeon Joo. A seemingly typical kdrama pairing of a rich-guy + charismatic-gal, except they are in different worlds. I really loved the concept of the two worlds here; I'm an avid reader of webtoons and the use of it in this drama was just phenomenal. Another thing I loved about the story is the concept for the villain. It was so unique as well! I would've given the story a score of 11/10 to be honest. That's how revolutionizing the plot of this drama is. (I would explain later why the score for story is 9.5)
Acting/Cast
This is the best on-screen coupe chemistry that I have seen. Never have I shipped two people as hard as this Lee Jong Suk-Han Hyo Joo pairing. Every emotion was on point; from stranger-meets-stranger to lovey-dovey cuddling to tear jerking scenarios, these 2 are perfect. The only reason I gave this a 9 is because the supporting cast was really lacking in terms of delivery and realness. I can think of two roles in particular that could've been given to different actors and it would've resulted to a much better outcome. I think Ji-Soo would've done a lot better in terms of being that stout, untalkative bestfriend of Kang Chul. I also think Park Soo-Bong could've been given to a different actor. They are the only ones that to me looked really awkward, but that doesn't mean that the others are of the hook. Overall, LJS and HHJ really carried the score for acting and cast, but all the others pulled them down, that's why the score for this is 9.
Music
OST could've been a bit better. Aside from the main theme song 'where are u', every other song wasn't exceptional. Fits the scenes well, but not good enough to be remembered outside of the show
Rewatch Value
The plot is so unique and original that regardless of the flaws of the show, coming back to it can always be considered a good idea. Keep watching it other directors and screenwriters. This is how you make a unique show.
Explanation
The reason I gave the story a score of 9.5 was because of 2 problems
1.) Stretched storyline after episode 11 ---- The danger of creating a really unique story was running out of ideas throughout the whole series, and it was kinda evident near the end. After episode 11, episodes 12-15 looked really similar in terms of structure, flow, and what's gonna happen at the end of the episode. Just because you end the episode on a cliffhanger, that doesn't mean the viewers can't tell what will come next. I felt like the right thing to do here was to drag the happy moments between Kang Chul and Oh Yeon Joo at the start so that the rising action and climax doesn't feel as streched out as what happened.
2.) Lacking ending --- One of the main criteria of a good drama for me is being able to give justice and closure to most of the characters of a show and the plot. An example is Descendants of the Sun (4th favorite drama of all time). They allotted a whole episode to give closure to almost all characters in the story as well as close the plot. With W, they were able to properly close the plot but they failed to give justice to the two main characters for me, giving a rather incomplete-feel to their ending. The main leads were put into so much action and drama throughout the series especially Han Hyo Joo's character, who was 80% tensed up in this drama because of all the things she had to do and think about. It would've been soothing for the viewers' eyes to see their happy ending moments by at least 30 minutes of screen time, but in this drama we were only given 5-10 minutes.
Overall
This is one for the books. This is a must watch. (Actually my 3rd all time favorite Kdrama)
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
However, when I read the criticism towards the show, I kind of agree with it. The story was too rushed and all over the place and it often lacked internal logic. It was too much, too soon. It would probably be much better if the writers took time to develop relationships and some reasonable pace for twists and turns. The first 3 to 4 episodes were absolute deabak and left me craving more of the same thing. Unfortunately, the story became a bit messy later on.
I also loved Han Hyo Joo's acting. I wish I could say more about Lee Jong Suk's acting, but honestly I can't since he kept distracting me with his good looks. I don't know if he is a good actor or just a good looking one. I'm not sure I would care either way, to be painfully honest.
All in all, I still totally recommend watching this show and seeing for yourself what the hype is about. I can't give it a high rewatch value mark, though, since the drama is about surprising twists and turns and once all the secrets are out it's just not the same when watching it again.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
