Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Watch the 2018 teaser and the official MV. Pretend this sequel series never happened
I watched this (and the movie) for Fluke Natouch, aka one of the best actors in the BL genre. Why, oh why did this production do this to such a great actor? How can anyone waste such talent?I'll put this upfront.
The lead actors did their job. The supporting actors (I mean Nuea and Tar because I've only watched their scenes amongst all the side couples)....were ok.
Unfortunately, they were given scenes to act out, not a story to tell.
It's the writing and editing that made this yet another disappointing sequel.
SPOILERS THROUGHOUT.
How not to ruin a much awaited sequel:
1) Do not introduce a bunch of new characters which don't play any role in the central plot/are barely related to each other, whom the audience doesn't care for.
2) Do not break up important, emotional scenes from the central CP with scenes from the new CPs, whom the audience doesn't care for.
3) Do not fill 80% of the screentime with the new CPs, whom the audience doesn't care for.
4) Do not skip the time between scenes and rob the main characters their chance to portray growth and emotion aftermath of those key scenes.
5) Do not break up the CP which fans are watching the sequel for without giving proper character development and resolutions to conflicts which make the break-up acceptable to fans.
6) Do not threaten to break up the said CP and then introduce a fairy godmother to suddenly change hearts and decisions. A forced happy ending is worse than an organic 'bad ending'.
--- Overly ambitious with too many side pairings ---
I feel cheated by the sequel. They could have just focused on Bank and Golf, and make it a movie instead of an 8-episode sequel where Bank and Golf are mere 'special guests'. In fact, the editing (or maybe the screenplay itself was written that way) was so choppy, I had to check different sources to confirm that the one I was watching is not a bogus one with parts left out. There was no closure of scenes and links to explain how Bank and Golf's behaviour changed between scenes - Bank in particular since he is understandably under more stress and shock from the turn of events.
How am I to watch their scenes when at the back of my mind is, "Golf had stagnated at their relationship from 5 years back but Bank, having thought Golf was dead, has moved on to a new lover." With that in mind, all I saw was the uneasiness and awkwardness on Bank's face when Golf showed affection during their time together prior to Golf finding out about Arm.
Actually, the different places where they now stand at posed a very good conflict to explore, but the series failed to make the best out of this potential. Instead, it introduced a bunch of characters I cared nothing for. If a second CP is necessary, just introduce one and build them up properly; don't be greedy and end up with a bunch of CPs which are just glossed over. I lost track of how many....4 side CPs? Just too many!
What mattered most wasn't dealt with, and it pained me as I watched the Bank/Golf/Arm scenes in the sequel. Worse still, I was forced to watch a sequence of those CPs spending happy times together at a point in the plot where I ought to be weeping with one half of the CP I was watching the sequel for. The worst thing was, there was no satisfactory pay-off at the end of all that pain.
In the final make-up scene where Bank was finally showing some hints of romantic happiness being with Golf, the lapse in continuity from his previous reactions towards Arm and Golf made it difficult for me as a viewer to connect. By then, Bank as a character had lost his charm. Also, I wasn't convinced of his love for Golf anymore. He even said it himself, "Precious love cannot replace a precious relationship". And we know he chose the latter.
No, wait. He didn't. Arm made the choice for him.
--- Character actions and emotions do not make sense ---
So Bank now loves Arm, in his own words. But why? As the audience, we've seen how Bank and Golf fell for each other. Though illogical, we accepted how Golf pretended to die in exchange for what seemed to be the only way to a future with Bank. It moved our hearts.
If the sequel had wanted to resolve the conflict of choosing between a short-term "love" and a long-term stable relationship, the least it could do was to show us how the new lover won Bank's love, right?
In the teaser, Bank was shown saying, "First love is not easy to forget. It has been 5 years, but I still cannot forget him." The scenes where Bank went to revisit places with memories of Golf, and his 'grave', left a deep impression on me.
So how did Bank get over that first love and accept Arm?
Perhaps the sequel thought that with the 5 years that passed, fans have forgotten those feelings from My Bromance 1. But it should consider Bank's own words: "We don't know how long a person will remain in one's memories. But in order for someone to stay with us forever, we have to keep them in our hearts, not just in our memories."
How am I to believe in the central conflict where Bank has to choose between his two loves, just because Bank at one point tells us, "Bank loves Arm. There is really nothing between Bank and Golf. Bank and Golf are just brothers"?
The memory montage in the last episode was a joke. In the part 1 120mins movie, there were so many tiny details, moments which set our hearts fluttering: Golf noticing an eyelash on Bank's nose and removing it for him, Golf's many silent moments watching Bank.
But in this part 2 8-episodes series, there were no memorable moments. The happiness I felt from Bank when he was with Arm....I don't sense the same from the scenes he shared with Golf.
For me the most memorable scene associated with the sequel is the teaser where someone asked Bank how long he is willing to hold a secret love for someone. He replied, "Forever."
This was the Bank I loved. I was searching high and low for that in the series proper. If only the series had expanded on what was presented in the teaser.
My last complaint about consistency irritated me to no end that in such an important scene, there is a lapse in logic. In episode 9, where we see Bank and Golf spending time together after their reconciliation, Golf gifts Bank with the ring he retrieved from his grave. Yes, the one Bank left by his grave, which I thought was Golf's. In the movie, we saw Bank wearing a ring after that so I'd thought he took his and left Golf's at the grave. This was further confirmed in the sequel when Golf asked Bank why he wasn't wearing the ring he bought him. But in this post-reconciliation scene, Golf took out that ring and put it on Bank, while Bank took out his and put it on Golf. So....I guess all along the ring left by the grave was Bank's, while Bank took Golf's so that he can carry Golf everywhere he went. Please, is it too much to ask for consistency at least within the sequel?
--- The only good thing about the plot ---
At least we found some answers to the questions from the movie regarding that lady who appeared out of the blue with Golf when he returned from America. This sequel was announced in 2018, after the BL scene begun to take flight in Thailand. I wonder if such closure had been planned during the movie back in 2013/2014, or if this was just an after-thought to plug the gap.
Even to the every last second, the series had to put a big question mark on my face. Why did Arm have to die? Does it change anything if he didn't die?
--- In conclusion ---
What a waste of the acting talent that is the two Flukes. Especially for Fluke Natouch, who has been the more active one in recent years. I know he is capable of so much more. Both Flukes delivered their scenes well, but there is only so much they can do when the writing is bad. A good actor can only connect with the audience through a well-written character and plot. Similarly, a well-written character comes to life when acted out by a good actor. I'm only giving 3 stars in the acting category because of the two Flukes, and mainly for Fluke Natouch.
The lack of character consistency and development sucked life out of Bank and Golf as characters, destroying the persons I grew to love from the movie. They failed to get me to empathise with them and I felt......nothing.
To the production: You had Fluke Natouch on your cast and you delivered this. Shame on you.
My recommendation is to just watch the teaser (released in 2018), the official MV and then episode 9. That's good enough closure to the movie.
3 stars for music, solely because of the existence of the MV which combines all the GolfxBank cuts.
Rewatch value of 1 star only because it ride on the goodwill from GolfxBank from the movie. Even for Fluke Natouch I wouldn't rewatch this as an independent work.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
This is one of the first BL that changed Thailand.
Some ratted this drama very badly. And I will not. First, because you need to discard the remake from 2016 that was really bad. First, because the respect between the original movie from 2014 and the series staring Fluke Teerapat and Fluke Natouch. Before talking about the series, you need to watch the original movie. The story about those two brothers (not blood related) who felt in love against an homophobic father and a society who fought against LGBT during that time (the story is between the 90s and early 2000s).But, while the story is about homophobia and acceptance, this drama 5 years later show the changes over time. In 2015 the LGBTQI in the U.S can marry legally. So, while Golf "died" in 2013 and went to live with his Half-sister in the US, he saw the changes and when he came back in 2018, the wold had changed toward the LGBTQI community. So, this series make sense, and people who rated it so low didn't even try to understand it.
On top of that, if I remember correctly, this was from the real life of real people. (For example, the group Axis, from Gondola Entertainment is where the two characters came from). Look online for more info.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Let me wallow in my disappointment.
What a way of ruining a story, I tell you. It's so obvious the writers were trying so unbelievably hard to milk a story that didn't need to be milked because it was good enough the way it was.~Story:
A mess. I don't even know where to start because there is just so much going on and so much cramped together in such awkward ways that you can't even call this a cohesive story. We had like six couples and all of them were irrelevant. Yes, I'm including the main couple as well. All their stories felt like scrapped drama plots that were meshed together to form a messy story.
This would have been so much better if they got rid of most couples and turned Bank and Golf's side into a movie. Maybe add Tar and Nuefar's story to give a little spice to it. Everything would have been so much simpler and easier to follow if they had edited shit out.
~Cast:
I don't even know. It's kind of decent enough to not make you cringe, but there was a big lack of chemistry between everybody that ended up looking poorly on every episode. I'll talk a little about most couples:
-Bank/Golf: Irrelevant. They were so dry and awkward it was hard to watch. I was surprised at how bad Bank's actor performed here since he did a great job in "Until We Meet Again." Golf's actor has not changed much and it shows. You can tell he's heterosexual because his acting came out too forced and restrained.
-Tar/Nuefar: The best of the bunch. It was still dry as hell, but the chemistry decent enough to make me believe them... a little. Tar's actor NEEDS to work on expressing emotions because he was straight up flat through the whole thing.
-Meka/Hungray: Irrelevant. One looks like a crackhead and the other looks like he's on his way to become one. Again, they were trying so hard to act gay it was kind of sad to see. Let's NOT mention the sexual assault.
-Nut/Kung: I kinda like them. Not the best actors out there, but good enough to make me pay attention. This is one of those couples you wish had their own drama because their plot actually has potential for a little short series.
-I honestly don't even remember the names of the other couples so I won't mention those.
~Editing, pacing, and direction:
More like terrible, terrible, and terrible. I don't even know what the vision was. Like I said, this whole drama looks like a bunch of different scrapped plots randomly put together. And, PLEASE, don't make me mention the unnecessary and slow paced music interludes. This series is what unprofessionalism looks like.
I don't recommend this to anyone. The story is very unnecessary and does not add anything to the original. You should watch the movie and stop there because this drama isn't a must.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
What happened to Paan?!
Okay it explains what happens to everyone in the show BUT never says anything about where Paan is and what happened to her like did she just disappear??? Wtf like I am so confused with this someone if anyone knows please tell me. WHAT THE H3LL HAPPENED TO PAAN?!?!!?! I MUST KNOW CAUSE IT DRIVES ME CRAZY EVERY TIME I WATCH THE SERIES AND SHE'S JUST.....GONE!!! So please please pleaaasseee if someone could like shine some kind of light on this that would be like awesome. I love Fluke's acting like always he brings so much emotion to every single movie/series he is in never fails to make me cry. The story was good enough for me to watch it more than once but I think they could've explained more what happens with everyone and again why Paan wasn't in the second series. Anyways someone please just help me out with this....Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Decepcionante
Toda a mídia que foi feita em cima dessa série me fez pensar que seria um estouro. Fiquei bem decepcionada com o roteiro dessa sequência... a trama central era (ou deveria ser) sobre o retorno de Golf e como Bank ia assimilar isso, só esse núcleo, se bem trabalhado, já poderia dar uma boa história. Mas ao que parece, na intenção de "encher linguiça", por não conseguirem muito assunto sobre o casal principal, criaram uma série de histórias paralelas, algumas com início sem lógica ou fim sem noção, ou as duas coisas. Ficou tanta coisa misturada, que o casal principal mal aparecia em alguns episódios, e como se não bastasse a péssima atuação de vários atores e a quantidade de histórias aparecendo simultaneamente sem nenhum elo que as ligasse, eram histórias fracas, roteiros vazios. Sinceramente, me decepcionei demais com essa série, criei muita expectativa e quebrei a cara. Até a abertura ficou ruim, a trilha sonora não agrega nada, e só poderia ter ficado pior se tivessem separado de vez o casal principal (confesso que tive medo disso).O único ponto que posso colocar como positivo é a atuação do Fluke Pongsatorn, sempre impecável. mas ainda assim prejudicada pela falta de qualidade da série.
Apesar de ter assistido a série duas vezes para tentar entender alguns pontos, não recomendo.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Marija Dolly Milosevic
0 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Barely scratching the surface
As the title says, this story - barely scratched the surface - it was good idea, but poorly executed. I loved the energy through the movie, and the chemistry was decent.Let's get back to the story, the fact that one of the main characters was dead in the 1st part of this movie, bringing him back was and (in my book), will always be an amateur move. I am a bit sucker for happy endings but the whole idea of "playing dead" was unnecessary. It has to be very strong reason for something like this.
Just as the 1st part problematic moments were rushed. Emotions were fine, some even touching. I missed more affection, but there was some...like not totally - we are in relationship and our intimacy is deep stare into loved ones eyes and hand holding. It was more than that, yet not enough. I did not expect Pornographer (Novelist) but I started to hope that more and more real intimacy will be portraited in movies and TV shows from 2021.
Overall, one more bl checked on my list that was not total waste of time. If you are picky and have no intention of watching every single bl ever filmed you might skip this one.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Love Fluke Natouch
I started watching and so far it’s been interesting. I love Fluke Natouch . He is an awesome actor. I am also glad to see the other Fluke too. They both have such good chemistry together. There are other side couples which seem to fit with the title . I find them intriguing but I hope to see more of the two main characters. I am also glad to see some of the same actors from the first series. The music in Ep 4 is nice . I am wondering how much COVID-19 affected the total production. That said I applaud their efforts under trying circumstances.Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
A series that fails to excite
I've just watched on YouTube the first four episodes of this eagerly awaited sequel to My Bromance: The Series that aired some years ago. Unfortunately, after Ep. 1, the drama dissipates and the storyline becomes weaker and weaker, they've added four new side couples while the main couple doesn't have enough to do and too often there's just music playing on top of silent dialogue. I have to say the studio that produced it is capable of much better work so it's rather disappointing, a view also expressed by most of the people leaving comments.Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Worst story telling ever
Initially I was very excited to watch this series as the movie was absolutely heart breaking and who doesn’t love a happy ending? Both Flukes were more of supporting characters. The entire series seems more focused on the other couples which has nothing to do with the original movie. It leaves little to be desired as the entire series seems to only be leveraged on the movie’s title and the directorship and storytelling was absolutely bad... I was absolutely shocked that it’s by the same director who did the movie as it seems like it’s done by two different people instead of the same person. As much as I would like to see a proper remake of this... I Guess this is why “Love of Siam” ended at where it was and will always be a master piece in our memory and hearts same goes for the movie of My bromance and not this series ?Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
