Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
The cutest
I was so hyped when this adaptation was announced, having watched Kieta Hatsukoi and Gemini x Fourth's past series, and I was not disappointed. Their acting is amazing, especially Fourth, who has the best expressions and shows nuanced emotions so well. His internal conflicts can be deeply felt without the need for any words; he's so good, my son T-T. Gemini also did a great job with his quiet and clueless character. I feel like they're both really similar to the Atom and Kongthap in real life too.I also really liked the secondary couple; they are so pretty, and they have amazing chemistry. Mudmee is so sweet, and Half is such a saint. Much better than the Japanese adaptation, where they were kind of bland and not very remarkable. The story also felt very natural and real, like actual teenagers' first love.
The things I liked the most about this version are that they erased the homophobia from the original work and the inclusion of mothers. No words can express how happy I was when we discovered that teacher was not homophobic like the Japanese version; I was tearing up for real.I have conflicting feelings about the amount of homophobia scares, though. I think it was maybe more than 5 times where they made us believe that a character was going to be homophobic for a long time before reveiling it was just a misunderstanding or something. It felt bad, and for me, a queer watcher, I really felt the fear Atom felt every time, because that's how it feels to have to come out; it's always scary, and especially for a teen, it's so nervewracking to feel like you're going to lose someone you love every time you come out, no matter how much you know they love you.
The other thing I have to criticize about this is how much Mudmee is influenced by her (very sucky, might I add) "friends". They never had a good thing to say and gave the worst advice, and Mudmee, despite questioning them, always ended up following what they said only to rediscover that Half is a very patient saint.Atom also got carried away by his own bad thoughts, but at least he has the axcuse of the very real fear of being rejected by homophobia, and Kongthap was also a patient saint throughout their process.
Overall, I think this was very well written. I loved the cast and the OSTs. I cried a little at the end, and it was great.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
It's A No From Me
I realize this is adapted from the manga, and not the Japanese series Kieta Hatsukoi. That being said isn't Kieta Hatsukoi also an adaptation from the manga.My understanding is gmmtv is adapting 9 volumes of the manga but if what I saw in Episode 3 is from the manga I can see why Japan left it out.
Why would Mudmee (Hashimoto) be coaching Atom (Aoki) on how to win a man when all she's doing is writing that man's name on an eraser.
Hashimoto and Aoki were adorable and wonderful because they were so inept in the romance department. They provided one another comfort and friendship and bounced ideas off of one another and supported each other. They were best friends once Aoki realized she would never love him and Aoki realized Ida was his love.
So in conclusion I think gmmtv did what it does best in it's remakes. That is cast a popular pair that has amassed a large fan base that supports them no matter what allowing them to serve "questionable" script that will be accepted without question because it's Gemini and Fourth.
I will not argue my opinion because that's all it is, is my opinion.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
In My Top 5 BL Drama's of 2024!!
I love this drama so much, coming from the standpoint of a person who hasn't seen the original or the manga. I think the cast really brings the characters to life & it's not cringey like people keep saying it is. the show is very cartoonish/silly in nature BUT that's what I love so much about it. very innocent and sweet, the main & side couples love stories are just so fucking adorable. Atom has become one of my comfort characters & I just hope people won't let the negative reviews scare them away from this masterpiece!! <3Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Don't expect anything
One of my favourite and most re-watched Japan bl series was kieta hatsukoi. May be that's why, I'm a little bit disappointed. I'm not saying this series is boring or something like that.. but the 1st episode didn't work for me..May be I compared it too much with the original one..
But the chemistry was awesome and I love fourth as always.. and he tried to be cute as aoki as possible.. but no-one can beat Aoki for his cuteness..
In my opinion, Gemini was not like the original ida.. the confusing face was there but he was missing something.. I don't know.. but it would have been weird if he copied exactly like him, so some Gemini touch is necessary.
Sometimes I felt like they added the extra scenes just to make a 1 hr episode. Some did work and some did not (They could have executed a couple of scenes beautifully, but they didn't ) don't worry guys.. luckily the chemistry always works..
And the production also was not that good.. or may be because of the editing.. no idea, something was lacking
And the music was not that good in the 1st ep.. we expect the best songs from gem4th series and the original version is famous for their music.. so let's wait for the best to come in the next episode onwards.
Overall I like to see more of Gemini fourth and the stories of atom khongthap but also, I'm always comparing this series with the original one..
So those who didn't watched kieta hatsukoi, then it's the best series.. for those who watched it, then don't worry you get to see more of their hidden stories and Gemini fourth chemistry..
For me first episode was just average.. as I said something was missing, may be I expected too much.. but my review can change in the future, because I don't have any expectations from now on.. and I'm surely going to watch the rest of the series because of gem4th and I trust the whole team.
Oops forgot to mention mudmee and half, they were cute and lovely. Loved the whole cast.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
MSP 2.0????
ALRIGHT BESTIES, LET’S TALK ABOUT THIS GEMINIFOURTH SERIES BECAUSE IT’S GIVING CHAOTIC TEEN ENERGY, AND I’M HERE FOR IT. But first, can we just agree that Fourth IS Atom? Like, no notes. This kid isn’t acting; he’s literally just living his life on screen. Fourth, my goofy king, you EAT every time. Anyway, let’s break this down because I’ve got thoughts, and they’re juicy.ATOM. He’s the definition of “Oops, my bad.” This boy is so messy, clumsy, and absolutely clueless that he accidentally starts a fake situationship with Kongthap. Like, sir??? Mudmee was throwing her shot, and you’re out here giving “Sure, I’ll take the bullet instead.” And then he’s like, “Wait, why does this feel kinda right??” The drama, the chaos, the gay panic—chef’s kiss. Fourth was born for this. He’s got the comedic timing, the awkward vibes, the “someone protect him at all costs” energy.
KONGTHAP? Eh, he’s cute or whatever. Let’s be real, Gemini is playing Tinn 2.0 from My School President. Dreamy, protective, zero personality crisis—like, bro, we get it, you’re perfect. But also… give me some flavor, ya know? His whole arc is “I’m scared to tell my mom I’m gay,” and I’m over here like, BABE, THAT’S YOUR BIGGEST PROBLEM? Okay, slay, but I need more spice. Still, Gemini and Fourth’s chemistry? Ugh, they serve every time, no crumbs.
NOW THE SIDE PAIRING… OMG, WHAT EVEN??? Mudmee and Half? Messy AF, but lowkey the drama I live for. Mudmee slapping Half? YES MA’AM. Girl said, “You wanna act up? I’ll act up harder.” Their whole relationship is just a series of unresolved arguments, but it’s giving “toxic but I love you anyway”. Like, I hate it, but also, I can’t look away. ALSO, can we talk about Mudmee and Atom’s friendship?? They’re such ride-or-dies, giving each other trash advice like “just wing it, bestie, what’s worse can happen?”. UM EVERYTHING???? but it works somehow. I want what they have.
THE PLOT?? IT’S A CIRCUS, AND I’M BUYING TICKETS. Starts with a misunderstanding, ends with a love story—classic rom-com vibes. Atom is whiny, yes, but it’s cute because he’s out here living his first-love fantasy. And don’t even get me started on the Cinderella play episode. ATOM AS CINDERELLA??? I was SCREAMING. Fourth was so chaotic and adorable; I had to pause just to recover.
FINAL VERDICT: Would I rewatch it? Abso-freakin-lutely. It’s the perfect comfort series with romance, friendship, and that sweet teenage cringe we secretly love. BUT HELLO??? Can someone give GeminiFourth a serious, mature series next year?? I’m so tired of the fluff. They’re giving “potential to destroy my soul,” and y’all keep giving them happy puppy vibes. Like, give me angst, drama, betrayal—something juicy, please. Anyway, I’m off to buy some Euro Cakes because product placement works on me. Byeee!
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Not perfect but it's watchable
I think they wanted to copy the japanese style including some of the thai culture and elements but it was not really good??I didn't watched the Japanese adaptation nor read the manga so I absolutely don't know the story and its characters. However, it's kind of disappointing when it didn't get my attention as expected and that in a BL, I was mainly happy and cheering on the side couple which is a hetero couple! I appreciate and enjoyed a lot Half and Matmi but I also like the friendship between Atom and Matmi.
Except the ton of product placement.. And Usually I'm aware of it and I don't mind it but this one was indeed a bit too much, I still find it funny, cute and somehow entertaining (although I found myself being on my cellphone playing some games and the episode playing on the background lmao). Not the best, not perfect but it's watchable to spend on my free time.
It also tackles some youth issues which are also relatable but I still don't think I'll rewatch.
The only thing that I love the most is the OST but also the couple of Matmee and Half lol
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Qué le han hecho a Gemini y Fourth??
Tenía bastantes expectativas de esta serie porque salían Gemini y Fourth y realmente pensaba que podía ser mejor que la versión japonesa, aunque no me había gustado demasiado.Al principio bien porque me recordaba a la versión japonesa ligeramente, pero luego se volvió pesado y aburrido, aun así me lo termine porque a mi personalmente no me gusta dejar las cosas a medias.
No se lo que le ha podido pasar a Gemini y Fourth, pero no tienen esa química que había en My School President o incluso en Moonlight Chicken. Es como si ninguno de los 2 quisieran estar actuando aquí, los besos son horriblemente incomodos. Nunca habría pensado que iba a decir que me ha gustado más la pareja hetero, en un bl.
Por no mencionar en el que cada capítulo había 1m 30seg de publicidad, además de toda la promoción q hacían los actores en la propia serie, siento que este bl era más para generar dinero con GeminiFourth, porque saben que sus fans se lo van a permitir todo y comprar lo que ellos promocionen. Parece que la GMMTV no se quería en esforzar en hacer algo bien, porque sabía que aun así habría gente que diría que le ha encantado solo por los actores que salen.
El único episodio que vale la pena ver es el 7, los demás son todos mid, y para ver el bl, ya está la versión japonesa que es 1000 veces mejor que esta.
Necesito que Japón prohíba que Tailandia haga remakes de sus bl, sobre todo si se trata de la GMM.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Cute but nothing groundbreaking
Idk why the reviews are giving this so much hate lol. It’s a perfectly serviceable Thai adaption of the manga/japanese original. Is it as good as either of those? No. There were things I liked about it and things I didn’t.Kieta Hatsukoi relied on a combination of slapstick comedy mixed with heartfelt moments. This was far less slapstick and also removed some of the more dramatic moments from the manga (ie, the homophobic counselor). So it did result in it being less funny and less emotional simultaneously. Maybe it’s not fair to compare the two, but it is an adaption so it’s kind of hard not to.
I also hated that they turned the play into a musical lol y’all are talented but I can’t 😭
That being said, it’s just a sweet high school drama lol. Like perfectly mid imo. It actually follows the manga pretty closely, even the ending is pretty much identical.
If you’re just looking for something low-thought and cute, this fits the bill.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
A charming Thai adaptation of a romance series, blending humor and heartfelt emotions beautifully.
Overview: "My Love Mix-Up! Thailand" is a charming adaptation that brings the beloved Japanese story to a Thai setting. The series revolves around a high school love triangle involving a shy, awkward boy, a seemingly indifferent yet caring love interest, and a close friend with hidden feelings. The Thai adaptation maintains the core elements of the original story while incorporating local cultural nuances.Storyline: The plot follows the protagonist, who accidentally ends up with a girl’s eraser and becomes the subject of gossip. This misunderstanding leads to complex feelings and romantic entanglements involving three main characters: the protagonist, the love interest, and the friend who harbors unspoken affection. The series skillfully explores themes of identity, love, and personal growth.
Character Development: The characters are well-developed and relatable, each with their own unique struggles and growth arcs. The protagonist's journey from uncertainty to self-awareness is portrayed with depth. The love interest's complex emotions and the supportive friend’s quiet strength add layers to the narrative, making their interactions compelling and genuine.
Acting and Chemistry: The cast delivers strong performances, bringing authenticity to their roles. The chemistry between the main characters is palpable, which enhances the romantic and emotional scenes. The actors effectively convey the subtleties of their characters' feelings, contributing to a more engaging and immersive experience.
Cultural Adaptation: The Thai version successfully adapts the story to fit local cultural contexts while staying true to the essence of the original material. The incorporation of Thai societal norms and high school dynamics adds a fresh perspective, making the story accessible to a Thai audience while maintaining its universal appeal.
Production Quality: The production quality is impressive, with attention to detail in both the visual and auditory elements. The cinematography captures the emotional tone of the series beautifully, and the soundtrack complements the narrative, enhancing the overall viewing experience.
Themes and Emotional Impact: The series handles themes of love, self-discovery, and friendship with sensitivity and depth. The emotional highs and lows are well-executed, creating a narrative that resonates with viewers. The series’ ability to blend humor with poignant moments makes it both entertaining and thought-provoking.
Final Thoughts: "My Love Mix-Up! Thailand" is a heartfelt and engaging adaptation that succeeds in translating the charm and emotional depth of the original Japanese series into a Thai context. Its strong performances, well-crafted story, and cultural relevance make it a standout romantic drama. Fans of the genre and newcomers alike will find something to appreciate in this thoughtful and well-executed series.
If you enjoy romantic dramas that explore complex emotions and relationships with a touch of humor, "My Love Mix-Up! Thailand" is definitely worth watching.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Light Coming of Age
I love Kieta Hatsukoi, it's one of my top favorite shows ever, but it ends really soon into the story of the main couple. My Love Mix Up gets to explore the relationship in full and with differences that makes it stand out on it's own as an adaptation. This is in reference just to the two shows, not to do with the manga at all. Both Atom and Kongthap learn to grow as people through their relationship with each other. Their mile stones of physical intimacy like holding hands and kissing are so sweet. The parts that I dreaded the most, but turned out to be a very memorable subversions was the classmates doing the play and especially the teacher. In the Japanese version it was a homophobic teacher, but in the Thai version, the teacher turned out to be also gay and both he and his boyfriend become mentor figures. It's so moving to see an elder queer mentors help Atom and Kongthap how to navigate being queer in a world that's definitely not always friendly. The mothers being so supportive and loving to their sons is so heartening as well.I didn't like Mudmee's storyline. It's the same in both the Japanese and Thai versions. I don't think violence is funny or warranted in the context of any of the situations shown. Her strength is a funny gag, but not when it's to physically assault someone who did not do anything to deserve it.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
There was so much potential
I wanted to love this series because I really like GeminiFourth, but this just fell short for me. I didn't dislike it, the cast and OST made it an enjoyable watch but I expected more after how incredible My School President was. Speaking of, there were way too many references to MSP (the only one I genuinely liked was in ep 11) and it felt like a desperate attempt to please fans by giving them a hit of nostalgia. The story felt slow and fast at the same time and Atom's clumsiness was downright cringey sometimes, which is so different to how I felt about Gun's clumsiness in MSP. I also didn't feel like I knew the characters that well. Kongthap was so one-dimensional despite being one of the leads, and I don't think I'll remember any of the side characters after a week (except my girlie Mudmee ofc).But enough of the bad, I would still recommend watching this series mainly for the cast and OST. Gemini and Fourth are obviously very talented and they deserve all the recognition they get. They're both amazing singers as well, which is evident with how good the OST is, each song is a bop and I will be listening to this OST even after I forget the entire plot of this show. Chokun and Aungpao did a great job, wish Aungpao had more screen time tho. But I'm most impressed with Pahn, this is her first series and she absolutely slayed. She was able to deliver emotional scenes in such a natural way and she made me fall in love with Mudmee. Honestly, just watch the show for Pahn, she's worth it.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
A huge commercial with some story sprinkled
I'll just preface this review by saying: I treat this drama as a separate entity to the manga and the JP live adaptation. However as someone who has watched MSP and Moonlight Chicken, I do have a lot of expectation for this drama as GemFourth has proven themselves to be acting powerhouses. They still are really good actors, however the script does not give them an actual chance to shine, which is a huge failure for this series.I have a couple of things that I particularly enjoy:
1. Kongthap defending Atom against the homophobic jokes made after their stageplay.
2. The stageplay itself.
3. Kongthap and Atom scenes where they have actual heart to hearts.
4. Mudmee when she is endearingly honest.
5. Kongthap's confession episode.
6. Any emotional scenes with Atom.
7. Amazing OST.
The above were done really well, but here are my main issues with the storyline:
1. Series feels aimless - not sure how to explain this but there are no clear climax and therefore no clear resolution.
2. Pacing is off.
3. Script does not play into GemFourth's strong suits.
4. Horrible amount of product placements.
Look, I don't think this is a bad series. However this is far from being GemFourth's best. Objective rating would be a 6.5 from me but I am a sucker for mindless fluff so I have to give it a 7 for personal bias.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
