WORTH TO WATCH
Series ini benar benar hits different. Hampir dalam setiap aspek semuanya sempurna baik itu dalam ceritanya yang tidak biasa, OST yang sangat bagus, Produksi yang sangat sangat full effort, akting semua aktor dan chemistry main role yang membuat drama ini makin sempurna. Penonton dibuat sedih dan terharu, ikut dibawa merasa senang/sedih oleh akting pemeran utama yang sangat baik dan lokasi syuting yang sangat fresh. Saya banyak menangis ketika menonton series ini saking bagusnya. series ini di eksekusi dengan sangat baik.Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Obra de arte
Essa série conseguiu fugir dos padrões tailandeses de séries BL, apresentando um outro cenário, longe das universidades e da cidade grande, trazendo as aldeias longínquas e uma nova perspectiva.A atuação foi muito boa, Mix e Earth conseguiram transmitir muita química através dos olhares, até as crianças tiveram uma boa atuação.
A história é maravilhosa, envolvente. um dos pontos que eu destaco é sobre a personagem da Torfun não ter sido vilanizada, como normalmente acontece com as mulheres nos BL's. A fotografia da série é impecável, os cenários belíssimos.
Algumas pontas ficaram soltas, como por exemplo a forma como os pais de Tian conseguiram a doação do coração de Torfun, não ficou claro, apenas subentendido que foi de forma ilegal. Fora esse e alguns pequenos detalhes, a série me encantou e com certeza eu recomendo.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Un conte des 1001 nuits thaïlandais
Encore un revisionnage de cette série qui a été, bien plus qu'un gros coup de cœur pour moi.Dès le premier épisode j'étais accro, osant braver la fatigue quotidienne pour ne serais-ce que voir les premières minutes de l'épisode suivant à chaque fin de cession. Après chaque visionnage la série, ses paysages merveilleux, ses personnages riches en émotions, en questionnements, en histoire, me restent dans la tête pendant plusieurs jours.
J'ai beau retourner la chose dans tous les sens, je ne parviens pas à trouver de points négatifs à A Tale of 1000 Stars...
On sort ici des chemins habituels d'histoires estudiantines pour partir en pleine jungle dans un contexte complètement différent : enchanteur mais parfois aussi dangereux. Les décors naturels sont fabuleux mais l'histoire nous ramène bien vite sur terre avec l'avidité qui nous emplit de vouloir savoir ce qui va se passer.
On ne s'ennuie d'ailleurs pas une seconde tellement le scénario est bien ficelé pour soutenir notre attention au-delà même de la durée d'un épisode.
Les personnages portent la série en jouant avec brio, il incarnent tous des rôles dans lesquels ils se coulent à la perfection, aucun rôle n'est anodin, on reconnait certes les rôles principaux mais même les rôles secondaire (voire tertiaires) on leur importance, leur personnalité et leurs apports divers à la richesse de l'histoire générale.
La romance parait tout douce mais sait montrer des racines complexes bien ancrées dans le terreau de la réalité, jusqu'au dernier épisode on ne sait pas comment cela finira, c'est bien simple, je me suis souvent surpris.e à rester scotché.e à mon écran.
Quand le mot fin apparait, un sentiment de nostalgie vous envahit car on resterait bien avec Tian et PhuPha à compter les étoiles dans le ciel de nuit ou boire un thé sur la terrasse de la maison sur pilotis des professeurs tout en rêvant de fabriquer notre propre cerf-volant pour le voir voler au-dessus du petit village de Pha Pun Dao.
Maintenant, à vous de vous faire votre avis.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
The north of Thailand has started, a remote village on the border and the whole story can be read by anyone who hasn't seen it.
Story 7: already mentioned originality, I deducted three points from perfection for some illogicalities such as a heart transplant, mistaking it for a soul, stretching to the edge in some scenes, a completely unnecessary departure for two years to the USA at the end - when two beings love each other, that's how they should prove it to themselves and not that they go apart or that one of them, long grown up, has to obey mom and dad. It's just that two grown men couldn't grasp their love firmly by the scruff of the neck and face it, and behaved like sleeping flowers without mutual physical contact, which is inherent to love, infatuation and mutual attraction.
Acting 8: the way the characters were written, they didn't require any super-professional performances to the bone. I liked Tian the most (I won't mention their real names) then there was the 3-man line-up from Waterboyy The Series - Phupha, yes, he's nice, but that role was just as thankless as his previous roles in other series - INDECISION, Dr. Nam he was excellent and the role suited him very well and a friend from Bangkok Tul OK.
Sound 10: nothing to complain about, beautiful opening song
Processing 10: originality, professionalism
Tento seriál, který skončil desátým dílem právě dnes, hodnotím velice vysoko pro jeho naprostou ORIGINALITU. Pryč jsou školní lavice, chození po chodbách a žvásty o ničem.
Nastoupil sever Thajska, odlehlá vesnička na hranicích a celý příběh si může každý, kdo neviděl, přečíst.
Příběh 7: již zmiňovaná originalita, tři body jsem z dokonalosti ubral za některé nelogičnosti typu trasplantace srdce, jeho záměny za duši, v některých scénách protahování až za hranu, ke konci naprosto zbytečný odjezd na dva roky do USA - když se dvě bytosti milují, tak by si to měly dokázat a ne že jdou od sebe a nebo, že musí jeden z nich, dávno dospělý, poslechnout tatínka a maminku. Prostě že dva dospělí muži nedovedli svou lásku uchopit pevně za pačesy a postavit se jí čelem a chovali se jako náměsíčné květinky bez vzájemného fyzického kontaktu, který neodmyslitelně k lásce, zamilovanosti a vzájemné přitažlivosti patří.
Herecké výkony 8: jak byly postavy napsány, nevyžadovaly nějakých superprofesionálních výkonů do morku kostí. Nejvíce se mi líbil Tian (nebudu uvádět jejich pravá krkolomná jména), pak zde byla tříčlenná sestava z Waterboyy The Series - Phupha, ano, je fajn, ale ta role byla stejně nevděčná, jako jeho předchozí role v jiných seriálech - NEROZHODNOST, doktor Nam byl výborný a role mu hodně sedla a kamarád z Bangkoku Tul OK.
Zvuk 10: nemám co bych vytknul, krásná úvodní píseň
Zpracování 10: originalita, profesionálnost
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Beautiful!!!! EarthMix ❤️❤️❤️❤️
I watched it the second time and just did I bed it today. I liked it the first time I watched it. EarthMix’s chemistry was beautiful and they did a great job portraying Tian and Phupha. The plot is original and flow very well. I like that their love is so genuine and natural. This was one of my new bl and I really enjoyed it. The director Aof did a fantastic job directing the casts, and EarthMix. I also liked the village people and the children. This plot tells the story of a rich boy named Tian. One day, Tian got a new start on life and fulfill the wish of the passing Torfun. The osts is also beautiful and it’s now one of my favorite song.The story is beautiful and I highly recommend it.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
I don’t get the rave reviews
Saying that watching this series was such a massive waste of time is such an understatement. If you are considering watching the series and you read this comment I seriously implore you to NOT WATCH this. This is officially the worst bl series I have ever watched. And I have watched a lot. If you are looking for a romantic series that the relationship progresses this is definitely not it. But if you are looking for a series that they stare at each other stupidly like that’s supposed to be hot. It was cute and all the first few episodes but it just became stupid and silly with no progression. Then also one of the main lead tian cries every episode sometimes for silly reasons, if you still want to proceed and watch then by all means go ahead, have at it.The character Tian had one resting crying face throughout the series and the other one Phu had one smirk/smug resting face too. You are mad at your parents for saving your life and telling you what to do but you are so in love with Phu who also tells you what to do.
Yeah right.
To say I’m so mad that I watched this series in its entirety is once again an understatement.
I fast forwarded 75% of the time from episode 7. That’s how I managed to get through this.
I highly DO NOT RECOMMEND
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Just Once and Never Again
The ONLY thing I loved about this whole drama was the OST. Other than that, it did the truly exceptional job of boring me to tears. All that hype I fell for is something I regret.The acting was average. I would even say Mix's acting was lacking. He had such a limited range of facial expressions that I couldn't even buy into whatever mood Tian was supposed to be expressing because it just didn't come through. And the pacing could give a snail a run for its money.
Anything I may have found interesting was utterly erased by the sheer boredom it put me in. I've had a lot of hype about EarthMix, but thanks to this, I can't bring myself to watch anything they're in anymore. For this, once is way more than enough.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
I loved it BUT
(Additional Spoiler review at the end but you can read this part without worries!)I know my rating seems rather "bad" compared to the other reviews but I have to explain...
First, the story was good. It's a trope most us knows about but I think they executed it perfect. Now what bothered me? Well everything started to really ANNOY me with episode 9&10. Suddenly, there was a gigantic shift with another Dramatic change of a story line to spice things up which I genuinely did not understand???
I will talk about this part later.
The casting. I liked the casting but what I did not like was how monotone our main Tian was. Most of the time when he talks it felt really emotionless. I LOVE Tian though. His character growth was even more interesting than the romance part.
Music. I honestly don't understand how people could give this 10 stars. It's not bad or something but not 10 stars.
I think like modt of these cases people tend to rate everything 10 stars after watching the last episode.
Btw, I find the ending great, because who doesn't like happy endings? It was just executed very poorly imo. But as you can see many people loved it so maybe thats just me.
If you want to watch a Drama about a boy trying to define what his purpose is in life and additionally a "teacher" x Bodyguard Trope - then this is for you.
Spoiler part:
I didn't understand the logic of Phupha in the end. He told Tian to go away because he needs to live his life, to find himself- but at the same damn time Tian says his place is there wtf??? Phupha low-key sounded like Tian's mother and I really hated his mother I swear to god.
For a character who's Goal was to find himself, to be free, they ended this Drama really weird with him not even having to decide about his life.
Also, the last scene, I still don't get what he's doing there. Did he just leave USA without telling his parents - and now thats okay or what???
Oh, and his Mother saying studying education in the USA is better- this woman has no idea why does she keep deciding for him and the Father doesn't care.
Sorry, I love this Drama but seeing people only raring overall 10 stars when there were obviously some conflicts confused the hell out of me.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
There are certain small scenes that this show just gets right without over dramatising it. When tian realises his feelings for the chief and confesses it to his close friend over a casual conversation, his nonchalant reaction to tian’s confession also shows that the programme tries to normalise love towards the same sex as a preference rather than a gender specific emotion.
The sceneries used for this drama are vivid and the scenes shot under the flickering light of a candle are beautiful. Finally found a show that ticks all the correct boxes.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
*No Chemistry (Or Kissing) Between The Main Characters!*
If you want a smart BL drama with true connection, an interesting storyline and decent acting, this is not it.I wasn't planning on writing a review, but seeing as this tv show is so popular, I must ward off all of you who look for quality content because if you watch A Tale Of A Thousand Stars, you'll get super disappointed.
This is what's wrong with it:
1. The storyline had a good premise, but bad execution. The whole story was written badly, nonsensically, with minimal effort.
2. The script was awkward, empty, shallow, and cheap. No emotional depth, no feeling, no honesty or truth. It read like fanfic written by a 15-year-old.
3. There is no chemistry between the two MCs. This is my biggest problem. The character named The Chief was A. a bad actor, and B. seemed like he wanted to get as far away from Tian as possible. There were no intimate moments, no touches that felt honest, no yearning that rang genuinely, and NOTHING between the two MCs that I could appreciate.
(4. This is subjective, but The Chief was truly dislikeable and he reminded me of my ex.)
In any case, I am baffled at the support this tv show is getting. I would not categorize it as a BL at all. And if it's not a BL, then what is it? A waste of time!
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
