Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Not bad!
I was so disappointed with the way My Extraordinary ended, especially because I had high hopes for it to be a really exceptional drama, and not just another "kill the gays" story based on homophobia. But, because I liked the cast of ME so much, I was happy to give this series a watch. Here are my pros and cons:PROS
TRANS CHARACTER IN A DECENT MAIN ROLE. So happy that Jenevive, while a mostly comedic character, was given a main story line and, at the same time, a degree of substance and not just another joke character portrayal.
GOOD BALANCE BETWEEN COUPLES. So we had two LGBTQ+ couples and two straight couples. Fine by me. None of them were given short shrift, so good on the writers and directors.
ACTING. Some really good performances! Enzo was great (as usual), so were Nico, John, and Keijee.
THEME SONG. Absolutely LOVED the opening OST. Catchy tune, I was always dancing and singing along.
END SCENE. Loved the ending scene with Romeo and Jenevive. So cute! "Normal" and "happily ever after" relationships featuring a trans character are so rare... a trans character's story is usually "never gonna happen." This is progress.
CONS
INCONSISTENCY WITH STORY. There were issues. 1) Why was Markie such a dick to Clark? Sure, Clark was hitting on Markie, but he didn't do anything wrong. Markie was going along with it -- twice -- but then just insensitively dumped Clark the moment Daniel was in the picture. We were just supposed to ignore that, I guess. 2) The end focused on Miguel's homophobia against Markie and Daniel, but (other than a brief scene in an earlier episode), Miguel's hatred for Romeo and Jenevive as a couple was not addressed. Why just Markie and Daniel? What's Romeo's story? Always gay? We don't know. 3) The forgiveness of Miguel was just too fast. He was such a homophobic asshole through the whole series, then he sheds a few tears and all is forgiven? And mom is "proud" of him, within just a few minutes? No... just no.
JANICE. I'm probably in the minority, but I couldn't stand Janice, with all her "I'm more than just a beautiful face" and "I'm not just some trophy girl" comments. Gurl... you're not exactly Miss Universe, get over yourself. Total turn off. Both Mateo and Moises can do better.
MIGUEL'S STORY. I would have been happier if a little less time was devoted to the Miguel/Jane relationship and more to Miguel's homophobia. As it was, Miguel just came across as an ass who needed a lot of therapy sessions. A couple of sentences about his military dad's influence just didn't cut it.
Still, I enjoyed this. It was nice to see some of these actors again. I'm giving it 8.0 out of 10.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Seriál s kratšími epizodami a námět početné rodiny a všech lidiček kolem vypadá zajímavě, ale dlouho jsem čekal na dvojici Markie - Daniel (až od 6. epizody). Do té doby se tam řeší drobné problémy kluků a holek, v prvních dílech dokonce téměř "hlavní roli" hraje divná transka Jenevie (pro nás divné, pro pinoy produkci naprosto normální). Zahráno solidně, nejvíce se mi líbil Mateo a malá Merry. Tvůrci mohli více zapracovat na jediné gay dvojici, ta jejich "pusinka" vlastně ani nebyla a závěr vyšuměl divně. Proto je mé hodnocení celkově jen průměrné.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
so good
oh my god guy's this was so good it had everything that i look for in a show/series and the actors made me feel for what all the charters were expiring throw there acting .the story was something special it give an amazing look it into the struggle of living your own truth due to exactions or fear that the ones you love will not accept the true you. and also in that it gives you a look into the other side of being able to accept someone for who they are due to the the views of man and to see a person of being strong and deserving of respect of every man and women in the view of it not being part of the norm.Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Não é uma maravilha, mas é aceitável
Assisti a série por que já era fã de alguns atores e isso me chamou atenção, mas confesso que tenho medo das séries Filipinas, pq do nada eles tas am um final totalmente sem lógica e a gente que lute pra aceitar.Apesar de ser uma série de baixo investimento, atuação não tão boa e roteiro com muitos furos, foi a primeira vez, repito, primeira vez, em que a mulher trans não é apenas a alívio cômico ou a caricatura. Ela tem um papel relevante e faz parte da trama central, e isso me encantou.
Os assuntos abordados são pertinentes. Além da já citada Genevive, temos uma mãe e 4 filhos e 1 filha. Dois desses filhos são gays, um deles é extremamente homofóbico e o outro, assim como a filha, não estão muito preocupados com a sexualidade dos demais.
Pelo que entendi a mãe é viúva. O filho homofóbico vive um relacionamento complicado com uma moça, que insiste em permanecer numa friendzone incômoda. Me incomodou muito o preconceituoso não ter nenhuma punição, fiquei indignada com isso. Apenas "se arrependeu" e tudo bem. Oi???
Enfim, pelo menos teve final feliz. A ost da série é linda, eles aproveitaram o ambiente e fizeram uma boa fotografia e filmografia. A atuação não é nota 10, mas dá para passar. Enfim, gostei e recomendo.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
