Un drama au rythme lent, facile à suivre
Un synopsis intéressant. Le thème abordé est traité avec sensibilité et avec beaucoup de poésie. Le visuel est joli et le jeu d'acteur convaincant. L'ambiance tend vers une certaine plénitude bien que certaines scènes nous montre la douleur et les incertitudes des protagonistes. Le contraste entre les scènes où le bruit tranche avec le silence des conversations en langage des signes est parlant et nous permet de comprendre le fossé qui s'est creusé entre les personnages.Les points négatifs ne m'ont pas empêché de finir ce drama en quelques jours, car malgré tout, je l'ai trouvé bien fait.
Les points qui peuvent rebuter certain :
- Le classique "je te quitte pour ton bien". Nul besoin que je m'étende sur ce sujet....
- La romance, somme toute mignonne, mais avouons le, dénuée de passion. J'aurai aimé, peut-être un peu plus de passion, plus de battement de coeur... Ici, l'impression qui a dominé fut plutôt deux amis super proches avec en bonus une grande affinité.
- Bien que l'emphase soit mise sur l'amitié, et j'avoue que la relation entre So et Minato a été agréable à suivre, j'ai un peu de mal avec le protagoniste qui sort avec la petite amie de son best pote, pour au final rompre avec elle et la rendre à son best pote.
- Le rythme lent du drama.
- C'est personnel, mais je n'ai pas trouvé les personnages secondaires intéressants.
C'est donc un drama que j'ai trouvé assez agréable à suivre, mais que j'ai regardé parfois en accéléré.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Review in one sentence
This is my first jdrama and it is the best jdrama of the year. Acting of all the actors were perfect. There are some people who didn't like Minato and Nana, but I like them both. All the characters are kind hearted peoples. Loved it so much. I love the piano bgm and the ost , both matches with this drama perfectly. If you wanna try a jdrama I will definitely recommend this. Don't miss this gem. I'm a person who doesn't cry on watching sad drama, what I meant is, I will be sad for sure but my tears won't come out but this is one of the few dramas which made my tears came out rolling again and again. So thank you, I enjoyed that emotional part very much too. Thank you to all the actors and staff for your hard work.Thank you for reading:)
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Drama that touches the soul deeply
While scrolling through Instagram reels, I stumbled upon a clip from this drama's first episode featuring Sou and Tsumugi's reunion. Intrigued, I decided to look up the synopsis, and boy, was I in for a ride! But you know what? It wasn't just the heartbreaking storyline that got to me; it was the sheer beauty of the writing. Sometimes, you come across something so profound that it hits you right in the feels and leaves you in tears.There wasn't a single dull moment in the drama, thanks to the engaging conversations between the characters. I felt like I was experiencing the story from each character's perspective. Every little detail seemed to hold a deeper meaning, and by the time I reached the final episode, I was treated to a whirlwind of emotions and uplifting moments.
Of course, creating such a masterpiece requires exceptional performances from the cast, and I must say, every actor nailed their role perfectly. They truly brought the characters to life, evoking genuine emotions with every scene.
This drama left a lasting impression on me and taught me valuable lessons. And who knows? Maybe when I rewatch it, I'll discover even more layers to appreciate.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
For me, editing was the issue. No, maybe it was the relationships
This was a slow drama, which here was a good thing. Some of the scenes were just beautiful and you could feel the emotions of the characters. The music was lovely, and the use of silence, was, overall, very effective. The acting was, for the most part, understated and not overacted as can be seen in a lot of Japanese shows.However, the timeline of the script and the way it was edited decreased my enjoyment of the show. This story would have been more effective if it had been told in a more linear fashion, rather than the heavy use of short flashbacks. As I watched this, my mind was busy seeing what I would have done differently when making this show. There wasn't enough of their high school storyline to get me to feel and understand their relationship. As a result, their relationship felt superficial, and I had a difficult time seeing what all the fuss was about. They loved music and the sound of each other's voice, but what else?
Also, I have a difficult time feeling that theirs was a great love, when she was, to all appearances, living her best life getting ready to move in with her boyfriend. Consequently, she felt like a "love the one you're with" type of person.
Then, there was the editing itself. Numerous times I thought there was something wrong with my tv, when the scene cut at a strange place and the screen went white or black. Was that supposed to symbolize time passing? I don't know, but it was jarring.
Apparently, I'm in the minority for not loving this one. I wouldn't recommend this show, but I wouldn't tell people to run away from it either. Some of the scenes are very effective, but since I couldn't see the love between the main characters, and since so many of the choices they made would, on the surface be noble, but on closer look I found their choices to just be selfish.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
I'm not comfortable
2/10 and it barely make It to 2 .I barely made it to the last Episode , and it made me so uncomfortable , I know it's a drama speaks about deaf people or people who can't hear and their struggle I understand .
A lot of things were so annoying .
Is it about the three main characters or about the story or about the other characters besides the main characters, I mean they are all great and respectful people , but what's wrong with this ?!!!
the female character being dumped at every chance the writer had and then it all goes like we are trying to make the female character happy!
Seriously?
The two male character the girl dated were so selfish and stupid , they were like I feel like this so I decided this immediately , the first one was like I can't handle the pain of not hearing your voice again so let me hurt you instead of let us figure this out together and he dumped her in the most uncool way , he was like I have someone I like let's break up the end.
The uncool part is he immediately goes to his best friend and tell him I don't want (the female character) you can have her, is she an object ??!!!!
later on the other guy she was dating after a long time was the main male character's best friend , exactly .
And of course she was dumped again by this character too , do you know how ?
The same way the main male character did , the guy knew her past with his best friend.
The first 6-5 episodes were boring for me , the last 4 episodes there were more things happening ,I don't think I'm gonna recommend it to anyone.
The one thing I really find it amazing is that I was able to see through deaf people's everyday life , normal things we thinks it's easy and granted it was not for them , I learned a lot during this drama .
They usually put a phone ringtone with a flash thing because they can't hear when the phone is actually ringing , or wearing a special watch To wake them up in the morning, or how they use apps that turn speech into text .
I was happy to learn those small details that we can't see or think about.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Beautiful and intelligent
I was really worried about this drama being frustrating seeing as the premise itself is about one character keeping a secret and initiating a break-up, followed by years of no contact — but that wasn't the case at all. The plot was realistic, the characters so mature and complex, and the script was surprisingly intelligent and beautiful because of it; there were a lot of places where annoying tropes could've come into play but the drama subverted it every time and instead the characters worked things out with communication and emotional connection.This was just a beautiful drama to watch and it's so comforting from beginning to end. There are no villains, every side character is multi-faceted, and it was a beautiful story about people reconnecting and not only bridging the language gap, but also learning to accept each other and the passage of time. 11 episodes was perfect for the pace of the plot but I also wish I got so much of them.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Well thought-through drama, maturing is realizing your own mistakes and owe up to them.
A drama to never forget. The low rewatch value is not something to be negative about as its an unique drama! Its definitely engraved in my mind as these sort of disabilities dramas are rare and creating awareness through this type of content is definitely appreciatedAlthough the storyline aligned with my predictions, it was still a pleasure to watch how the relationships between characters developed; and as it’s a Japanese dramas, everything is dealt with maturity.
The title Silent fits this drama perfectly; the director(s) somehow managed to ‘’fill’’ the screen with sound although its supposed to be silent in a real life scenario.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
A healing drama is just like a donkey . . . I mean onion
On the surface it is a short, slow burn romance with low angst. We need to peel back some layers to find the deeper meanings.The ML is a tortured soul whose near perfect world collapsed in short order due to his gradual loss of hearing. He doesn’t know how to deal with it, so he became withdrawn and pushed everyone away. He tried to join the deaf community but finds that he is still on the outer because he was not born deaf. He came to the sad conclusion that EVERYONE sees him as being different and there is nowhere he truly belongs.
I believe that one of the motifs of the Show is how society divide people based on many assumed and perceived criteria into different groupings. Both real and invisible barriers are here to segregate and isolate them into smaller cliques.
Our need to belong creates pressure points in our social interactions. It can be exhausting and debasing when we run into unyielding barriers. How horrible it is when you are yanked from a comfortable reality into a new one where you are confused and lost.
It was fortuitous that the ML met a kind deaf girl. She befriended him and helped him to learn the sign language. It is not acceptance but at least he can function again. Their relationship is ambiguous. The girl is clearly interested in him, but he is afraid of commitment and shows no inclination to take their relationship to the next level. The girl is happy to stay in the friend zone as she has him all to herself. However, all that changed when the ML's ex-girlfriend ran into him by accident and started a chain reaction that changes several lives.
For me, the Show is a beautifully crafted story about rediscovering love, friendship, sacrifice and the need to compromise. I don’t want to give away the plots regarding the SML and SFL but let's just say that I'm getting serious second leads syndromes by the end of the Show.
From my perspective, the first half of the Show is very well done. There are lots of backstories, raw emotions and misunderstanding before the fateful reunion. The show took its time to explore all this. It was never going to be a joyride but the writer-san skilfully weave the story back and fore along the timeline so that we know how each character arrives at their current circumstances. There were plenty of broken psyche that needs healing. They get patched up enough to keep functioning but not completely healed. The amount of baggage carried by the ensemble cast will keep a caravan of camels fully loaded.
Unfortunately, while the Show start to untie the knots and salve the troubled souls in the second half, it is a slow process. The pacing of the show becomes almost meditative.
The healing and exploring requires a lot of dialogues between the OTP and sometimes side characters. I think the writer-san wants to show how difficult communication can be even though it is based on a common language. We ended up with a mix of sign language, written words, phone apps and normal conversations. It can be slow going as the ML has to keep the signing slow and simple so that the FL can keep up. It is like watching two primary school kids trying to communicate. They do resort to writing sentences on paper when it got too complicated.
In the end, the bulk of the breakthrough came in the last episode. All the affirmations and compromises are nutted out then. Some of the best scenes are also found there.
The FL worked hard to live in his world and she cajoled the ML into compromising his unyielding stand. It is a fragile middle ground but one they can call their own.
The acting is great with a lot of depth. Without spoken words, they need to emote with their facial expression, posture and their eyes. That requires real skills.
The loveline of the OTP is sweet-bitter-sweet. It is ashame that there is almost no skinship.
I can recommend this show but you have to be in the right frame of mind to appreciate it.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Loudest Silence
What is this? Who cuts onion here? Why did my eyes puff like hell after finished watching this? It's not even a melodrama with a tearjerker or dying character.I like how the production team makes its total silence when it's Sakura's POV. It makes me feel like I'm taking a peek at his life without any sounds. I can only depend on the provided subtitles to understand what they're talking about. Maybe it's because ads break when airing on TV, but the randomly-ended backsound doesn't sound comfortable in the ears.
STORY - They brought me into a sea filled with each of the character's stories. It's a whole package of love, best friend, and family. Dealing with knowing you are losing something you take for granted while considering important people around you. There goes your butterfly effect which spans 8 years.
I also like how the writer makes Sakura being careful before confirming his relationship. He looks up various references related to their future before taking one last step. On the other hand, Aoba one sidely proposes to give up everything without asking Sakura what he actually wants makes me lower story rates to 8.0. Is she really ready to welcome their future together? If it takes another route of compromise, I can easily give it a solid 9.0.
ACTING - Standing applause to actors and actresses who have to learn and memorize sign language for this drama. All actors handled their character very well. Sakura's outburst, Aoba's despair, Togawa's dillema, Kaho's dwelling with prejudice, Sakura's family, Aoba's brother, Haruo Sensei, Toga Sensei and other actors are all well received.
MUSIC - I know "Subtitle" by Official Hige Dandism and have been loving it long before watching this drama. This drama makes the OST hits different and deeper than ever. The lyrics reflect the character's feelings well and convey them in a beautiful melody. Every time this song played in the background, it made me more immersed in the scene.
I much enjoyed this drama. Many of the problem's climaxes happened at unexpected times. That made me sit on the edge, anticipating what would unfold later.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
A silent world is not a sad world
Ahhhh! Such a slow burn, coping, sweet and selfless story.It gives such a huge understanding about the people that suffer hearing loss. They all tries to help him cope and they all love him.
It is natural for a person to think that his disabilities can make everyone around him suffer but the only thing that makes human suffer is the pain of losing someone.
The story is such a cute one where everyone was trying to understand eachother feelings. I saw the drama beacuse I liked the minato visuals but damn the story was way to good. I loved how everyone tried to adjust to each other just beacuse beacuse of their friendships.
I hope everyone in real life was as understandable as the characters in this drama.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
SO GOOD!!
BEST DRAMA IVE WATCHED IN A WHILE!!!! i’m going to protect sou and tsumigi with my life ????? this drama made me cry and smile so much throughout. i finished it in literally 2 days, that’s how much i enjoyed it. i wish i could rewatch it again :(((( HIGHLY RECOMMEND.Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
A simple yet meaningful Japanese romance drama
This was a story about a girl (Tsumugi Aoba) who was dating a boy (Sou Sakura) in high school. Around the time they were graduating, the boy was gradually losing his hearing and decided that he did not wish to burden by continuing the relationship with the girl. He did not tell the real reason, but simply texted about liking another girl. The girl only found out his loss of hearing after they met up coincidentally 6 years later. During that time, she was already dating another boy from the same high school who was also the boy’s friend.11 episodes with 50-60 minutes per episode. ‘Silent’ this drama was indeed rather quiet, understandably so when there was a lot of sign language used.
It was neither fast-paced with action nor were there plenty of things happening. However, there were no draggy scenes. Even the usual tearjerker scenes were quickly over and done with, yet not having the feeling it was insufficiently done. I feel that everything in this drama was portrayed in typical Japanese fashion. Reactions were mild, actions were subtle, but inner emotions were strong yet not fully expressed.
This was best shown when Tsumugi and Sou met again and gradually became closer, yet not becoming a couple. Sou was hesitant because he felt lacking in himself, but Tsumugi was willing to move forward with him. These scenes were shown subtly, nothing overboard or dramatic, making them all the more touching and meaningful.
The acting was also convincing from the whole cast. Special mention to those who acted as hearing-impaired, Ren Meguro, the male lead and Kaho, who acted as Sou’s hearing-impaired friend. They were believable with their fluent and natural sign language. Haruna Kawaguchi, the female lead, was also natural in her acting. She was pretty and was always wearing nice sweaters (not related to the story whatsoever though).
Earlier in the drama, some people commented that Tsumugi saying numerous times to Sou before he lost his hearing completely that ‘I like your voice’, ‘I want to talk on the phone with you’ was emphasized too much to the point of being unnatural, but I think the director wanted to deepen the sad irony later that it was no longer possible for Sou to talk to Tsumugi naturally. In the later episodes, being able to hear him speak out felt so precious. I almost forgot how his voice sounded. He might have lost his hearing, but was still able to speak, just that not being able to hear his own voice became a psychological barrier for him to speak out.
This was a simple drama which touched on the relationship between people who couldn’t hear and people who could hear, how they tried to overcome their differences and most importantly, looked at the other in the present and not look at based on who they were in the past – I thought this was thought-provoking because many times we look at others based on our opinions of who they were and what they did in the past. We should perhaps try looking as they are right now instead of constantly living in the past. In this way, we can become our better selves and move forward together.
I would recommend this drama if you like to watch Japanese romance dramas whose stories tend to be simple and less dramatic. I would not recommend this if you do not like simple romance dramas and prefer dramas which are fast-paced, action-packed full of dramatic turns and twists, highs and lows like Korean dramas.
Some things spoken in the drama that I found meaningful
“Don’t look at someone based on who she was in the past. You should look at her as she is right now. If we keep lowering our gazes, we won’t notice if someone gently calls out to us. We must not avoid looking at them.” – Nana Momono (by Kaho) to Sou (by Ren Meguro)
“I got used to the fact that I couldn’t hear other people’s voices. But not being able to hear your voice, was the only thing I couldn’t accept.” – Sou to Tsumugi
“I won’t speak out. I won’t laugh. I won’t talk on the phone. I won’t listen to music. If these are so hard, I’ll stop doing all these. Even then, I want to be together with you.” – Tsumugi to Sou
(Tsumugi and Sou were sitting side by side. Tsumugi wrote each sentence separately in post-it notes and passed them silently one by one to Sou. I think it was her expression, she looked so pitiful while she was writing and passing the post-it notes that I couldn't help but cried with her.)
“Flowers make no sound yet they contain words that can convey many feelings.” ……. So true.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
