Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
A Love NOT So Beautiful
First of all is it even a remake of A Love So Beautiful drama because it doesn't seem like it at all. Well little changes are definitely fine but they literally changed the whole story. The original drama and also the Korean remake starts with the female lead confessing her love to the male lead and when she gets rejected instead of being heartbroken she decides to win him over. This scene shows that the female lead wants the male lead to know that she loves him right? In this drama I never once felt that Som-O loves Chadjen. Som-O didn't want Chadjen to know that she likes him. Like she was screaming at him for no reason, getting mad, behaving as if she's his best friend. And blah blah blahThey messed up the original characters so much like bruh you won't even believe it. Jiang Chen is a cold male lead and in my opinion one of the best cold male lead in dramaland but is Jiang Chen a emotionally unavailable when you need him. The answer is no. Yes he doesn't express his feelings that much. But he still cares about Xiao Xi, his friends and sibling a lot. He is a kind hearted person, he is smart, he is mature. On the other hand they first showed that Chadjen as a clumsy person in his early childhood, then a famous student in his teenage years and an emotionally unavailable person in his adulthood. Yes the male lead is a smart guy, he is a topper but in the original he was a normal student NOT A CELEBRITY. Chadjen was like a celebrity, like a real one. Many girls were approaching to him and he didn't know how to say no, Jiang Chen knew how to say no. Also Chadjen was a really good swimmer in the first two to three episodes but after that the swimmer Chadjen just disappeared. Why did they even had to add this swimming Chadjen thing. Was the male lead a swimmer in the original drama? No, he wasn't, only the second male lead was a swimmer. I bet they didn't do any kind of research before making this drama. There were so many things wrong with the character of male lead.
Xiao Xi is a bit childish but she's responsible enough about most of the things. In the original the female lead becomes an independent woman. And watching her character development, felt like a beautiful journey. Xiao Xi made so many efforts for Jiang Chen, like waking up early, cooking for him, trying to be a better student, trying to get his attention and so on. Som-O is not Xiao Xi at all, she cooked for him once and then nothing else. She is so stupid but then she wanted to be a doctor like seriously!!!! Then when she failed her admission examination and she wanted Chadjen to tutor her. Why he should help you? Don't you have any self respect? Som-O is the most annoying character ever. I didn't like her at all.
Neo did justice to Wu Bo Song's character as Tao but still something was missing. Neo is a good actor and that's why Tao was likable. But the writing kinda messed up lots of things. Lin Jing Xiao was tough and cool but she was cute and kind at the same time. Emma was the right choice for this role but she wasn't anything like Lin Jing Xiao, she tried to act tough and cool but failed miserably. Lu Yang our chinese Nobita was so cute and funny but New was kinda annoying.
Xiao Xi's father supported her in everything, this father daughter duo was on same team in their little family. But in this version what's wrong with the father? He's so irritating, controlling his daughter, being overprotective for nothing. Your daughter Som-O isn't even that pretty or smart. I don't know why but I didn't like Som-O's mother too.
They messed up the main plots, this 5 students are friends, they like and care for each other a lot. They had bonding and their those chaotic, sad or cute moments was everything but we got nothing. In this version they just met up became friends instantly, no development at all. The poem Jiang Chen had written for his father literally made me cry but what the hell Chadjen wrote? Jiang Chen had a reason, strong desire to be a doctor but it was never shown in Chadjen's character. After admission examination failure Xiao Xi became mature, she made herself better in terms of many things. Don't let me get started on that stage play thing.
AND why the hell they turned the School Doctor to a senior student? I wanted to see the doctor student cute interactions again T_T
Every single thing about this drama is nonsense to me. I hate this drama a looooooooooooooot.
Dew is a horrible actor. Prim is below average. Some people were saying that she is a good actress but she acts good only in thriller dramas. I mean does that even make any sense. If she was a good actor, she would have acted well in every genre.
GMMTV used to be a company who used to make good adaptions or at least watchable one's. I don't know what happened to them after F4 Thailand: Boys Over Flowers, they started doing a poor job adapting new remake dramas. In GMMTV 2023 they announced 6 remakes project and all of them failed miserably when it comes to storyline. I knew the same was gonna happen to this one too after watching Faceless Love, Cherry Magic, Find Yourself and Beauty Newbie, still these dramas were watchable for the first half but A Love So Beautiful was a NIGHTMARE. I am so glad my nightmare finally ended!
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Over long, repetitive, improbable, terrible acting by leads
This series has 18 episodes. When you remember that excellent Thai series with strong plots, attractive actors and full of action like Dangerous Romance, 10 Years Ticket, Blacklist, The Gifted, etc. had only 12 episodes, you think that A Love So Beautiful must be packed with events. In fact, nothing happens. The heterosexual love story goes from Year 10 in high school to past university graduation. The girl is attracted to the unrelated boy who lives in her parents' house because his mother is overseas. She spends her time alternately swooning over him and being exasperated with him. He has no idea about this and stands around like a block of wood with a puzzled expression. He is very tall and looms over her. She wears a black pudding-bowl wig and looks awful as well as being an annoying person. It goes on episode after episode with no advancement. Even when they are adults and she invites him to live in her apartment, she is shocked to see a man's bare chest when he comes out of the bathroom with a towel round his waist. It is pathetic and unbelievable. I had to skim the supernumerary epsiodes from 10 onward and then gave up altogether. Weak acting by the leads, especially the male (Dew), repetitive, long drawn out, padded out, totally unworthy of more than one episode, and even that would have been a waste of time.Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
The romance was terrible but I had fun
You know those dramas where the ML acts like he does not care about the FL at all but, secretly, he is helping her and protecting her. We know how much he cares for her and loves her while the FL has no clue. Well, I think this is what the writers were going for and they failed. Miserably.I don't think that even those who are rooting for the main couple to be together see genuine love, from the ML's side, anywhere in their story.
There is love in the secondary couple but it doesn't feel satisfactory either. It feels like scenes put together without feeling. The words were said but they didn't transmit anything.
Now, the only one who shined: Tao, played by Neo. Everything that the ML needed to be, he was (I hope they finally give Neo the ML role he deserves)
That being said, between watching Neo without a shirt and the crazy nonsense of the plot, I have to admit that I had fun.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
TRASH SERIES
The plot mostly changes, the choice of wigs is very bad even though they can still choose good onesTo be honest, prim isn't suitable to be the female lead of ALSB because she's too pretty but I still like the totality
Don't watch this series because you will be uncomfortable with the male lead's acting
Female lead acting is good but because the male lead can't act everything is down
Dew, you better learn acting first because you don't deserve to be the male lead at ALSB
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
An Abomination remake of the Chinese
I want to keep this review short and simple. Like I'll not even explain the actors' acting and characters in this cause that's how confused and stupid this show was through these 18 episodes.First off, this series doesn't even deserve a 5.5 overall rating. Even this much was given only for Neo Trai Nimtawat's acting. In my opinion, Tao's character was the only watchable and likeable character because, at some times, I felt he related to the Chinese version.
I don't think I even need to rant on Chadjen's character[more like Dew's acting], but I did not like it.
The second couple was also okay, the ending for them was cute.
Som-o should just open her eyes and go for Tao instead of Chadjen because Chadjen doesn't deserve her love.
That's all.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
A Love So Questionable
In all honesty, I'm surprised I watched the whole thing. I mostly finished it for Neo, and the visuals. I was excited for this, especially since I love Prim, and would love to see her with a different on screen partner, but my expectations must've been too high. I'm not going to compare this to any of the other adaptations. Why? Because I haven't seen any of them. Therefore, this is a honest review from someone that didn't know how the story went, and just watched it without any knowledge. That being said, I may not have the best opinion because I haven't seen any of the other adaptations, therefore, I can't compare them on how good any of them are.The cast was great mostly, but it's just the fact that the storytelling wasn't great. I love Prim, whether it's for her acting or just for the actor, and I'd love to see her in a lot more, especially Romance, but this.. this was not it. Dew just has a stiff face with his acting. I doubt that's just how the character is. I've only seen Dew in one other thing, and that was F4 Thailand. He seemed to have pretty good expressions, although I don't remember it too much since I watched it last June, but it seems that in his more recent dramas, it hasn't been too well. I don't want to criticize his acting too much, but honestly he needs some acting classes to fix those expressions.
I'm not going to get too in depth with the story, for the fact that I have not seen how it is in other adaptations so the story could just be like that. But, I just want to say it didn't feel hooking. About half the series, 9 episodes I'm pretty sure, it takes place of Som-o in high school, and the rest of it is her in college and the adult life. I don't know if it's just the chemistry or the way the last few episodes were, but I just felt bored.
I felt little chemistry. I don't know if it's because I've seen Prim and Dew with a different pairing that I didn't feel the chemistry like the other pairings, but I just felt like they were awkward. Aren't they like childhood friends? So why would they be awkward with each other? Maybe that's just how the story is, but that's doubtful.
In all, this felt dragging. I didn't feel any fun with it during the last 4-6 episodes. The relationship was confusing to me, especially with the proposal with the second lead, like, I didn't even know they were together. I really wanted to finish it to see who would be end game, but in the end, I wish I wouldve dropped it.
The only thing good in this show is the high school life and Khao & News relationship. Wouldn't recommend to someone with high expectations.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
It’s cute so far!
I have only watched the two first episodes but it seems to be doing decently for me. I think this do will just end up being one of those “hey I have free time” shows, but the main characters are fun to watch and there isn’t anything that super annoying about it so far. I think I should also mention the other versions and how the Thai version will place for perspective so personally I think it’s so far better than the Korean version, but not too much better than the Chinese version. I’m not sure why maybe it’s because it’s only been two episodes ?but give it a shot if you have the time!Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Least fav of all time
I hate this series, and I didn't watch the Chinese or Korean one. So it's not because I'm comparing it to those two that I rate this badly. I just genuinely hate everything about it.Everyone except Tao is unlikable, I question the whole group's friendship and find everyone childish and selfish. Don't even talk about the acting, writing, or directing.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
not that good
i was quite excited for this drama i love the FL but it was just too long boring the romance was questionableI didn't like ML
also why the hell does chadjen and the fl meet for the firt time in three years or something and he is chasing you could have done that before now its like wayy to late I wanted to smash him the whole drama he was so stupid thwy took too long to become a couple and broke up too fast i also didn't like the other guy he was alright as a friend nothing else they relationship felt really forced and had no chemistry
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
It was frustrating to watch
I was super excited to watch this series because I love Dew. Its basically a friends to lovers trope, Chadjen and Som-O have been friends for over 10 years and in high school, they became friends with Khao, New and Tao. Together they navigate the ups and downs of life. So let's get on with the review:Rating- 6.5/10
I know it had high viewership in Thailand during its airing but hear me out. Khao and New's relationship was my favorite in the whole drama because there was understanding and communication. Khao was with New through both of his recoveries. Khao supported New to pursue his dreams of being a game developer. New proposed in the best way possible and the wedding was the cutest. Tao liked Som-O amd he showed it through his actions. He traded medals for her banners(the cutest istg) and was there for her whenever she was at her lowest. I get that Som-O and Chadjen liked each other but Chadjen put 0 efforts in the relationship. He never really had any time for her. He didn't fight for their relationship. He made New and Khao's wedding all about himself, I hated that. I was disappointed I only watched till the end to support Dew, nothing more. Hope Dew has a better series next time.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
mi mayor decepción desde que veo contenido asiático
después del excelente trabajo que gmm hizo con la adaptación de cherry magic, le tenía altas bastante expectativas a esta serie, la venía esperando desde que la anunciaron a inicios de 2023. la recompensa por haber esperado tanto: solo decepción. pudo haber tenido 10 episodios menos y habría sido lo mismo. agregaron demasiado relleno, subtramas innecesarias y la pareja principal simplemente tenía 0 química. en parte es culpa mía por haberle tenido tantas expectativas. le doy 4/10 porque en algunos momentos era tan cringe que daba gracia.Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Absolutely worst remake
Ok, first of all, I watched the original a very long back but I do not remember it. I only remember the basic plot, but I also do remember enjoying it a lot. Comparatively, this was an absolute nightmare.Even otherwise, if I have to comment on it as an individual story, I would still recommend you not to watch it. Very badly executed
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
