Voltooid
A_sol
0 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
apr 8, 2021
20 van 20
Voltooid 0
Geheel 9.0
Verhaal 9.0
Acting/Cast 10
Muziek 8.0
Rewatch Waarde 9.0
Questo drama vi stupirà. Almeno, a me, ha piacevolmente sorpreso.
Nonostante sia un po' datato, la sua magia cresce di episodio in episodio e alla fine ne sarete totalmente avvinti.
Ho iniziato a guardarlo un po' scettica. I personaggi mi intrigavano ma vedevo il riproporsi del solito pacchetto cliché completo di scambio di anime. Inizialmente, non vedevo l'ora che quella parte finisse anche se i siparietti comici che ne derivavano facevano molto ridere. Non ne capivo proprio lo scopo e sono rimasta dubbiosa per una decina di episodi. Lo continuavo a seguire soprattutto per Hyun Bin che ha un magnetismo incredibile e per la chimica che aveva con la protagonista Ha Ji Won (un'altra eccellente attrice).
Poi, però, la storia è decollata, mi si è palesato per bene il senso della trama e mi sono vista le restanti puntate a rotta di collo.
Che dire? La sceneggiatrice è riuscita a toccare delle corde interne profonde (non per nulla è la stessa di Goblin). Ha rappresentato, con sincerità, il difficile cammino di una coppia su cui non avreste scommesso 10 lire talmente i caratteri erano diversi. Eppure Kim Joo Won e Gil Ra Im trovano la loro strada superando ostacoli e ferite profonde. Anche i personaggi secondari sono bellissimi. Impossibile non amare Oska con tutti i suoi capricci e la sua sensibilità, Yoon Seul, prima la detesti e poi impari a capirla e ad apprezzarla (la sua evoluzione è tra quelle meglio scritte), la madre di lui rimane odiosa fino alla fine e, anche questo, ha un suo senso. In questo drama compare anche un giovanissimo Lee Jong Suk, un promettente cantante in bilico tra sentimenti contrastati per Oska. Una parte piccola ma, anche in questo ruolo, Lee Jong Suk ha dato prova della sua bravura anche se ancora acerba. L'unico interprete che non ho digerito è stato il direttore della scuola di stuntmen, Lee Philips e le sue due uniche espressioni che alternava di volta in volta. Peccato, avrebbe potuto essere un fantastico contraltare a Joo Won. Insomma, a volte, l'originalità un po' manca, però, il cast ha lavorato con una grande armonia e ha reso tutto coeso. Il finale è lungo e completo, non tralascia niente e nessuno. Uno dei più soddisfacenti in cui mi è capitato d'imbattermi. Lo rivedrei? Sicuramente si.

Lees verder

Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Voltooid
njshjtjnldm
0 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
aug 13, 2022
20 van 20
Voltooid 0
Geheel 10
Verhaal 10
Acting/Cast 10
Muziek 10
Rewatch Waarde 10
YOU`RE MISSING OUT IF YOU STILL HAVEN`T WATCHED THIS DRAMA. Still one of my favorite kdrama till now. The drama that made me a Ha Jiwon & Hyun Bin fan. It might be an old one but I promise you won`t regret watching this. seen this 3 times already because its real good. Not to mention, it`s funny.

Warning tho: Hyun Bin`s mom would get on your nerve. Like the typical rich mom that don`t like their son`s girlfriend or whatsoever. And of course, Bin too. The typical `rude and insensitive guy to the main female lead` during the first few episodes.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Voltooid
Barbietoureights
0 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
okt 15, 2017
20 van 20
Voltooid 0
Geheel 10
Verhaal 9.0
Acting/Cast 10
Muziek 9.5
Rewatch Waarde 10
I already watched this for almost 8-9 times in just a span of 3 years. The first and only kdrama that I have rewatched. It is also the only kdrama that I have watched  I6 episodes continuously for 1 day. It is really very funny and entertaining. It has contradicting elements that made it more unforgettable and heartwarming. It  is  very realistic despite its fantasy elements. Still my most favorite kdrama of all time! It's not a perfect kdrama in terms of plot and other technicalities. But the acting of the actors and actresses especially the main leads and the execution of the script really captured my heart. Hajiwon and Hyun Bin really gave life to their characters; amazing portrayal!! The script is also commendable because it has the  right mix of lines/scenario that are  heartwarming,funny,witty,melancholic and most of the time metaphorical. I enjoyed the metaphorical lines pertaining to the fairy tale characters; it's a modern day /realistic fairy tale indeed. Many kdrama fans might not agree that this is the best but for me; I cannot find any other drama that touched my heart the most and made me feel so hurt,happy and so  in love. This kdrama also made me realize that true love really exists and for me their love story is the best example of what true love should be.It didnt portray the main lead actor as perfect and so crazily in love; it's very realistic that the main lead still thought of the consequences of his actions and tried to control his love for the main lead actress..But in the end, true love still prevailed. I hope Haji won and  Hyun Bin can still have another drama together or a season 2.. Still Hoping.. :)

Lees verder

Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Voltooid
Ahlyb
0 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
aug 16, 2023
20 van 20
Voltooid 0
Geheel 10
Verhaal 10
Acting/Cast 10
Muziek 10
Rewatch Waarde 10

Totally in love with this drama

Watched this drama several years ago and loved it .Was so good back then .I recently decided to rewatch old dramas.I must say I’m more than in love this time around ..I understand everything better now ..
Everything is so on point .from acting to storyline ,to the ost..My fourth time rewatching and I never get tired.The progression is beautiful and right paced
No cringy moment
First drama I’ve watched, where the show is still good and not cringy after they start dating.
The chemistry between the leads are amazing
So I’m love with the fl she’s such a great actress as well as the ml
Even the love between the second leads is to die for
A very sweet emotional rollercoaster
It’s more than amazing how a drama is still so good after 13 years ….
A must watch!!

Lees verder

Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Voltooid
NaDa AbuRaya
0 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
jul 9, 2019
20 van 20
Voltooid 0
Geheel 10
Verhaal 10
Acting/Cast 10
Muziek 10
Rewatch Waarde 10
i came to watch this for the one and only Lee Jong Suk then i got stuck !!!!


the story were good written .. i laughed , felt love , sad and got crazy with every one of the characters !! i really enjoyed every minute of every second of the series !!!


the music was great and on point ... i loved the ost so much <3


the acting was so so good .. every one of them acted their role like it was his for real !! you could feel oksa hurts form his ex and how she manipulated him and hurt his heart .. then Sseon hopless love for him and how hurt he was then actually he was the one that made oska happy again with Yoon ...
then Kim and Gii omg they made me crazy from laughing all the time and how they got the chrachter so freaking on point when they swapped !!!


i really love the series so so much and watched for 3 times never felt bored at all ..

Lees verder

Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Voltooid
Daisuke
0 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
okt 18, 2018
20 van 20
Voltooid 0
Geheel 10
Verhaal 9.5
Acting/Cast 9.5
Muziek 10
Rewatch Waarde 10
Episode 1 - lovely intro countryside and "Indian Summer", then (thinks) is this meant to be surreal or just a mess of bad acting? As to "the beauty and body" of Gil Ra Im, is the above summary for real? it's extremely well hidden. But the production values are good…….As at ep.2 is this rather ridiculous - the idea that not-bad looking Hyun Bin (especially as s super rich CEO) would fall for plain Jane penniless Ha Ji Won defies credulity - plus I don't like the snide reference about "gays". Ep 3 why am I still watching this? the fashion? interior design? Oska? - oh, I forgot Lee Jong Suk……..are you there?? Ep 5 strangely magnetising, beginning to get into this but mainly for the side stories and bizarre characters of Kim Joo Won and OSKA, I like bizarre characters, but regrettably still not Gil Ra Im. ep 7 - well with a mother like that I now understand why he became so twisted, whew. This drama lit up with the gender bending, I'm not sure if Hyun Bin deliberately meant his transformation to be so camp, but either way it's quite funny. I like Hyun Bin here, he has a difficult character to portray but he in particular has managed to keep me watching. I would like to watch more by him but the dramas covered here don't sound appealing. The soundtrack of this drama is also really good. Ep. 13 Gil Ra Im's evening dress is -ahem- a little "de trop". I do love that house, the architecture and interior design are stunning [that library! but where did he get the time to read all those books?) Ep17/18 really an unexpected twist (not entirely liked by me) but SG now passes my excellence test of putting it on hold because I don't want it to finish. Having now finished the series I think it should have ended with Episode 19 and left the rest to our imaginings. What was a stylish, classy and intriguing series raising some real questions about identity and the penetration into this world of other dimensions was spoilt by - there's a good English word - sentimentality of a common romantic drama. Better to stop when it was still ahead. Maybe this stuff appeals to many people, but I feel it was a major error of judgment by the writer/producer. This is not to take away from all the good things in the series. I plan to re-watch as I suspect I missed many details the first time around. But I shall not be watching the last episode.

Lees verder

Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Voltooid
LilyAvram
0 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
aug 21, 2022
20 van 20
Voltooid 0
Geheel 8.5
Verhaal 7.5
Acting/Cast 10
Muziek 9.0
Rewatch Waarde 5.0

Drama un po' fantasy molto romantico.

Questo drama anche visto dopo più di 10 anni dal uscita é una bella visione.
Leggendo la trama si può pensare fosse un fantasy ma è soprattutto una commedia romantica.La parte fantasy veramente si poteva anche evitare sinceramente,rende solo la storia un po' più comica,però mette in mostra la bravura dei attori che si dimostrano fantastici.La storia di per se niente di speciale la solita lui ricco snob e con qualche fissazione oltre che una mamma insopportabile lei invece bruttina povera ma speciale.Si incontrano per un equivoco e lui non si sa bene per quale motivo inizia a sentirsi attratto da questa ragazza così fuori dai suoi standard.
Mille avventure più o meno divertenti e nasce un amore fantastico,nonostante tutta la difficoltà.
Molti attori degni di nota.
Bella storia e anche piuttosto emozionate.
Un bel drama da veder!

Lees verder

Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Gestopt 11/20
Cheerful Smiles
2 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
dec 22, 2019
11 van 20
Gestopt 0
Geheel 4.0
Verhaal 3.5
Acting/Cast 6.5
Muziek 3.5
Rewatch Waarde 1.5
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
I watched this drama because of the Strong Female Lead tag and my review and ratings are a result of that disappointment! I guess whoever tagged this as strong FL did it only because that character could do good physical stunts because otherwise it should have been tagged as the really weak FL!
The FL was a totally emotionally desperate character with very little sense of self respect! I kept watching it hoping that she would take a real stand against the ML at least one time but no, other than her outwardly tough appearance, she was a really easy pushover type character!
And that's what made me really frustrated because the character had so much potential but the makers just wanted to show an obedient and overly sensitive good little girl type FL masquerading as a really badass stunt person outwardly... Very Disappointed...

Lees verder

Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Gestopt 11/20
Sherayith
2 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
apr 1, 2020
11 van 20
Gestopt 0
Geheel 3.0
Verhaal 3.0
Acting/Cast 5.0
Muziek 3.0
Rewatch Waarde 1.0
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten

Headline: Spoiled brat stalks spunky woman who should kick him in the balls but doesn't

My title pretty much sums up this drama. I started watching it because it was rated pretty highly, but the more I watch the less I like it. The main male lead, Joo Won, has been incredibly unlikable for over half of this drama, and nothing he's done has redeemed my initial impression of him. He's a pompous ass who thinks his feelings and wants are more important than anybody else's, and he thinks it's a given that everybody should care about what he feels, but he doesn't see the need to care about how others feel. I really don't want to waste another 9 hours of my time waiting for his character development, because I already hate him. At this point I honestly don't even care if he improves tremendously in the latter half of the drama; I've already wasted my time watching 11 episodes of this drama go literally nowhere. I've spent more time urging the female lead to kick Joo Won in the balls, punch him in the face, and file a restraining order, than I have spent rooting for their relationship. Honestly, the worst thing about this drama were the kisses; I never once liked them. In fact, one of the kisses left me yelling at the female lead to use her nails to gouge his face, or use her knee to destroy his manhood, because he forced himself on her and instead of ACTUALLY defending herself (she's a stuntwoman for God's sake, she knows how and where to hit to make it hurt), she ineffectually hits his arms. That scene was beyond stupid.

This drama has it's moments, sure, but they are few and far between. The best character by far is Oska, the main guy's cousin. I love Oska; he deserved to be the main character. I shipped him and the female lead, they were actually cute together.

Lees verder

Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Voltooid
2013started
4 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
mrt 24, 2014
20 van 20
Voltooid 0
Geheel 5.0
Verhaal 6.0
Acting/Cast 5.0
Muziek 6.0
Rewatch Waarde 5.0
I did not like it... I watched it because of the high reviews, but I could not stand how he treated the woman in this story. This is baffling for me why many people actually liked it. It was just too much bickering back and forth = tiring after awhile. I had to put it to rest and continue, mute and just half watching it and jump to the end. OH MY GOODNESS, the ending was soo cheesy.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Voltooid
Taylorgg12
2 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
aug 17, 2012
20 van 20
Voltooid 0
Geheel 8.0
Verhaal 8.0
Acting/Cast 10
Muziek 9.0
Rewatch Waarde 8.0
Secret Garden and I had a love/hate relationship haha.
At times I thought this drama was fantastic at others I was like WHAT IS GOING ON! Although I did enjoy this drama I felt that the storyline was a little too all over the place for my taste.
I loved the main couple though, the were too cute for words even with all of their fighting. and Oska *sigh* amazing.
I did enjoy the acting of Ha Ji Won who has now become one of my favorite actresses and Hyun Bin's performance was to die for, several times I wanted to switch places with Jiwon haha.
Although not my favorite, this drama holds a special place in my heart.
I recommend this to anyone! Happy Watching :)

Lees verder

Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Voltooid
angeltopaz
2 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
mrt 19, 2012
20 van 20
Voltooid 0
Geheel 10
Verhaal 10
Acting/Cast 10
Muziek 10
Rewatch Waarde 10
Great drama, with the most kiss scenes (I think) Hyun Bin is great here, after this I've watched all his dramas so far and still searching for more.

His portrayal when they switched bodies is very amusing. Loved the story, acting, everything was great Ha Ji Won is great also. Her male portrayal was great.

Another drama where I wanted to reach into the screen and slap someone, his mother. Loved Lee Phillip, especially his English.
I've watched this one again also. Loved the OST especially 4MEN's 'Reason'

Another favorite of mine, also worth more than a 10.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Secret Garden (2010) poster

Details

Statistieken

  • Score: 8.2 (gescoord door 54,848 gebruikers)
  • Gerangschikt: #1450
  • populariteit: #57
  • Kijkers: 105,034

Top Bijdragers

31 bewerkingen
30 bewerkingen
23 bewerkingen
23 bewerkingen

Populaire lijsten

Gerelateerde lijsten van gebruikers

Recent bekeken door