Overpromises but under-delivers - a confusing tale of lost potential and underutilised characters

(Brace yourself, I was a Lit student so here's my walls of text. Sorry for typos etc.):

Enjoyable fantasy drama with a lot of undelivered potential, saturated with fan service moments, over the top product placements #coffeebay, misuse of secondary characters, all in support of a no longer justifiable love story of star-crossed lovers aka the Mary Sue leads.

I'm being generous in rating this an 8/10 (7.5 as a review) as I feel that all things considered the drama waivered about 4 episodes in with the start of the lovey dovey fan service moments, which, at the time I didn't mind, until the drama's quality continued to decline about episodes 7 to 8 and by the time of my bitterness in writing this, having just watched the ending, I feel that this drama should be rated at around 7.0 to 7.5 and that's if you aren't forgiving of the fact that this drama has a lot of plot holes and fails to continue its strength in storytelling Korean myths/folklore.

The premise of an action filled drama with a compelling love story backdrop about star-crossed lovers with intertwined fates was enough to entice me as I'm a sucker for those types of "fated to love you"/"loving you against all odds and through time, here and now" stories as a romantic. BUT to sum up, "Tale of the Nine-Tailed" to me initially felt like hopping on a rollercoaster, excited and anxious, then you get taken for a ride and reach a few heights, mid-heights, before then you're told to exit even though you've only had two minutes of enjoyment.

In sum:
* Weak, and illogical storytelling
* Underutilised secondary characters
* Underutilised fantasy/thematic elements
* Mary Sue leads who get what they what in expense of dispensable secondary characters
* Arbitrary, inconsistent and underfleshed rules of TONT fantasy land that make zero sense when you consider things altogether

LOVE/CHEMISTRY:
Look, I was aware that there were some people criticising Bo Ah and Lee Dong Wook as having no chemistry from the first episode in. I beg to differ. I did actually think that they had chemistry and felt that some of the initial judgment were a bit harsh as this was a new pairing. My favourite scenes were of Bo Ah as Ah Eum and their flashbacks as those really cemented the "star-crossed lovers with intertwined fates" theme. I loved the lake scene and especially Yeon crying as he gives Bo Ah the fox bead. I especially loved the parallel in Bo Ah crying and in the fox bead coming out, proving to Yeon that she was his reincarnated lover. I thought that that was one of the best scenes of this drama. I was also aware that at that point, some watchers thought that the reveal occurred prematurely and I disagree as at that point there was still a lot to play with.

BUT after that episode everything started to slow down and focus only on the "instalove" and THAT is the biggest weakness of their romance. The reliance on the past as a foundation of their present love. Although Ah Eum was clearly Ji Ah, she was still a different person, but the "instalove" prevailed and after the finding of the fox bead that that suddenly meant that although Ji Ah was still a bit embarrassed that essentially she already at that point loved loved loved Yeon, which made bloody zero sense. There were very little moments of building tension that is required when creating romance. The greater the tension, the better the climax.

Here, what annoyed me was that the writing was pretty much telling whoever's watching to assume that their intertwined past was enough to support their present romance and that they didn't need to talk in depth about that past apart from road trips here and there, over the top and cheesy dates featuring sponsors (I see you Coffeebay!), and out of the blue confessions that for Ji Ah's initial characterisation seemed out of the blue for her to say.

Conclusion - the romance lacked the necessary foundation for me to care, at least, to really care about why they loved each other so much because it wasn't believable. Why did they fall in love with each other in the present? I still don't know. Sure, Ji Ah was saved by Yeon and for that she might have been grateful, but why was she so open to loving a fox/non-human when she lost her parents to supernatural creatures? Wouldn't she harbour hatred against them? Why was it so easy for her to come out of her initial "strong girl" characterisation and suddenly become a lovesick girl whose only concern apart from the rescuing of her parents is her one and only love who she loves partly because there's an internal consciousness in her that remembers him (at least that's kind of implied) and partly because he's Yeon, the lead.

JI AH & YEON:
This is getting too long already but Ji Ah started off as a promising character. She was strong, got her shit together, but also had vulnerability from losing her parents and navigating her life all alone. But when she fell in love, and fall in love she did, she lost her strength and became a lovesick girl. The individual traits that defined her disappeared, and her love life became the focus of the show, so much so that that became her identity and the Ji Ah before Yeon became non-existent. Her life at the broadcasting station was very little spent, and really, I can't remember what was even the point of establishing that she works at the broadcast station when we saw very very little of what she did. The thrill of episode 3 in seeing Ji Ah as someone who was proud of her work, because it was rooted in something personal for her (finding her parents theme) was so admirable because she was a PERSON, her OWN PERSON, and not a person in love whose only identity is being in love.

Yeon, on the other hand, I thought was just a guy who was doing his best with all the responsibility bestowed upon him, and with very few people who could really understand the depth of that responsibility. BUT, now I have to agree with those other bitter watchers who say that he was selfish. He only did care about his own wants regardless of his self-sacrificing nature. At least, episodes 14-16 really shows that all he cares about is his lover and it doesn't matter what gets in the way, as long as he is happy. Actually, look, that is probably unfair, BUT the writers also ruined this character because Yeon lost his cool guy demeanour and became 50% baby and 50% cheese, which, to be fair, was funny in very small doses, but quickly became irritating because it made him look like an idiot, and made Rang's frustrations against him much more justified.

Also, what annoyed me was how readily okay the leads were in dispensing their friends. Of course, in fantasy land, sacrifice for a good cause is an honourable way to go, and dying for a great benefit is looked favourably upon, but where is the benefit in dying for the leads whose love story never really developed into a mature romance apart from the cringy sweet fan service moments? What was so important in their love story apart from the third party Imoogi that made sense for these secondary characters to be so readily available to risk their life for the happiness of one? Because they're a main character? It just does NOT make sense. Had the romance been stronger and believeable, and had there been greater foundational work emotionally, I would be all support but there was literally nothing apart from the third party Imoogi ruining their love, whose a questionable mission was never ever fully explained, that tested their love.

STORYTELLING:
What absolutely annoys me about the storytelling in this drama is a lot is implied, and nothing is explained. No debrief, nothing. Nada. There are many examples of this that sometimes you're like "Huh, they didn't explain that but oh, it's a new episode so let's just accept that that's what happened."

One such example is the rift between Yeon and Rang which was explained in one episode that although Rang believes Yeon abandoned him, that he didn't and never has. YET, we never get a full on explanation of why Rang believed this and what exactly happened in between those times. There was no debrief and after a few lines here and there, we are just made to accept that Yeon NEVER abandoned Rang and that Rang was just being an emotional baby.

Going back to Yeon's characterisation, the writers made him and Ji Ah too perfect that they made little to no mistakes and received the best of luck in almost all aspects of their life that they lacked relatability and became Mary Sue. It would have been more compelling had Yeon had to abandon Rang for a good reason and that his mistake in doing that led to the brothers' breakdown. Yet all the mistakes in this drama are mistakes that everyone else makes but the leads. It would have been better if the leads weren't so "perfect" - if Yeon had used Ji Ah to capture the Imoogi as his duty to the Gods before falling in love with her, if Ji Ah wanted to use Yeon to defeat the Imoogi but ended up falling for him.

I also didn't get the purpose of the Imoogi. For all the foundational work in trying to prove that the Imoogi was an all evil being, the taking Yeon's body to cause chaos to the world plan felt 'meh'. Personally, his plight would have been more believable had there been a long enough flashback scene where he speaks to Bok Gil and we were given enough view of the past for us to understand why he so badly wanted Yeon's body and why he had initially taken over Bok Gil's body. What I feel the writers could have done was shown a lot more of the past to set the foundation for the present.

Another example of the implied but not explained storytelling is when Ji Ah loses the fox bead to the blind fortune teller. First of all, how did she even know that she had it. She just said yes to the exchange and got Yeon. And although there might have been a scene where they discussed this, it was very brief and probably did not explain why she thought that the fox bead was useless. Also, if she's a director on the supernatural, wouldn't she be aware of its value so what was the point?

Another thing that wasn't explained was that the Imoogi wasn't able to read her mind? Why was that? I was hoping that here at least, and pertaining to the Princess Bari myth that she would have untapped supernatural connection, but alas, nothing. Nada. This was not explained. She was just a useless human after all.

OTHER COMMENTS (Okay I'm sleepy and I just need to get this out of my chest now. Tomorrow is a new day haha)
* There was also so much potential to delve into the stories of each individual from TOTNT that would have supported the creation of the fantasy world and probably helped establish in the believability of the rules of TOTNT's fantasy land. For example, Snail Bride could have got a flashback of her own instead of just having stories told about her. Green Evil Spirit could have also had a flashback about her own story. And definitely about the Imoogi exiting the well, and meeting Bok Gil, and even Bok Gil's own flashbacks with his wife. Even Moon Guy only had one episode and only appeared in the ending. The drama could have all these elements and could have allowed them to have greater importance instead of just making Yeon the main character who is an all-powerful, all-everything lead that saves the day and gets the girl.

* Continuing on from the underutilised characters. Soo Hoo could have been developed greatly - they could have given him the ability to heal, or at least allowed the side characters to also have powers. Ji Ah's friends could have also been a lot more useful and not just used as character decorations with very little screen time that it was actually hard to believe that they were at all even friends. Also Ji Ah's parents appeared only once or twice after getting out, what was even the point when it was almost as if they weren't even there??? The writers could have given them greater importance or even connected them to a fantasy source, because, after all, Ji Ah's mother had nightmares about her own child. Why was that? Again, that wasn't really ever fully explained.

*The fox bead - as much as this was set up as a very important element, it came and went and only appeared in the final episode, and again with very little explanation. If you're going to set up an important element (the fox bead is a love motif), you can't just forget about it and then realise that you set it up and tack it on the ending. It does NOT make sense.

* What happened to the villagers in episode 3? Whilst it was implied that they became the sacrifice that turned the Imoogi, there was no debrief about Ji Ah's story project there and about that island? Nothing.

* Also how did Yuri even fix her mess with her adopted parents? Shin Joo said he'd fixed it but why wasn't that even show. Even as a subplot, that was important in Yuri's characterisation. Why did they just ignore that?
--
Okay, that's all I can fit in. I feel better writing this review and getting those feelings out of the way. Don't get me wrong, there were some very good moments that I enjoyed, some cheesy moments that I enjoyed, but I couldn't forego logic for so long so here's this review.

Would I recommend this drama? Look, we all have different tastes and for the most part, I enjoyed watching this, but the ending really did leave a bad impression on me as I felt that my investment in the drama became exploited all for a "cool"/"unheard of" k-drama fantasy ending. If you choose to watch it and you start noticing what I've said, it's your choice to stick out; however, if you're part of the other camp that is able to turn off your logical reasoning and support fan service moments then by all means, watch this, be fan and go enjoy it. Otherwise, if you're on the fence, what's a few hours here and now?

Lees verder