Details

  • Laatst online: 19 minuten geleden
  • Plaats: in my Pillowfort
  • Contribution Points: 2 LV1
  • Rollen:
  • toetreden op: december 18, 2023
  • Awards Received: Flower Award1

Saeng

in my Pillowfort

Saeng

in my Pillowfort
A Secretly Love thai drama review
Gestopt 3/10
A Secretly Love
1 mensen vonden deze beoordeling nuttig
by Saeng
mrt 3, 2024
3 van 10
Gestopt
Geheel 1.0
Verhaal 1.0
Acting/Cast 3.0
Muziek 5.5
Rewatch Waarde 1.0

Third time's the charm? Not here.

They say "third time's the charm" in English, so I watched it up to the third episode. I won't watch any more.
This is now almost to the one-third mark, and I still have made no emotional connection to any of the characters whatsoever (maybe the hat guy, but that's just because I like hats).

The script is formulaic -- there's the secret crush from highschool, the womanizing tsundere alpha-male-type "top", the spurned ex-girlfriend, the comedic sidekicks, the engineering setting, the sick family member and subsequent money troubles etc.
The acting is bland and uneven -- it's probably mainly the script, but also I think directing choices.
The sets show the low budget, especially in the university spaces.

The GL couple also feels as if someone said: "Oh, GL is all the rage now, let's put that in." and nobody gave even the smallest thought on how a girls couple could work. All their interactions are so ... bizarre.

The roles for the main actors feels like they tried to squeeze into ill-fitting jackets -- especially for Konprot, who they tried to make into a typical "bottom"-type of character with his gentle demeanor, soft voice and the haircut. Thing is, he shouldn't have to: "Manly" men can also have secret crushes, and just because one is the "alpha-male" type, doesn't mean the other cannot be. (That's not to say that bulky and tall men can't be soft-spoken or gentle or shy or whatever, it's just so obvious that the people responsible here thought there should be a stereotypical "bottom").
I wonder what happened here. Did they not find other actors for the script? Did they not find another script for the actors? Or was it initially planned as a parody, and that information got lost somewhere?

Because this series could have been a great parody of the Thai college BLs of past years. Everything is already so over-the-top stereotypical. Then you get a cast that is actually not at all suited for the roles -- which could be played as a strength in a parody. If the director and the actors would have been just a bit more daring to really get into the absurd side of things, I would have had a great time.

As it is, this series is one I won't finish.

Edit: Please note how I did not say a word about subtitles -- even if those were better, the drama's problems would stay the same.

Edit 2: I watched episode 8 with half an ear. "I like women. I like Konprot now." The writer *actually* did a Gay For You and wasn't even ashamed to let Pluem say it out loud?! Unbelievable...
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?