What I loved about I Promised You The Moon is how it divided the fans of "I Told Sunset About You" Series. Without spoiling anything, the way they continued the story left a bitter taste to everyone but I still salute Nadao for telling these kinds of stories that are hard to swallow or talk about. With the direction of IPYTM, they initiated conversations among the audience, and as a result, the sequel took a hard hit among fans. Nonetheless, most are satisfied with how the series wrapped up.

I rated Story and Rewatch value 9.5 because IPYTM is just really hard to watch at times especially if you've fallen in love with the characters and seeing them mess it up is just saddening but one can't also deny the realness of how complex these characters are in this universe. Overall cinematography is still stunning visually just like ITSAY's. OSTS are still so good too.

I Promised You The Moon is a 10/10 for me and you have to watch and understand it on a deeper level to understand why it deserves to be a perfect 10.