Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Hit the top?!! More like stuck in the murky middle
I would like to start of this review by saying I had such high hopes for this kdrama. When I watched the trailers, read the synopsis and saw the cast I was immediately sold! One of Cha EunWoo's very first dramas, YES! Kim MinJae?! Who literally carried, no SAVED Tempted/The Great Seducer, the only shining glory from that drama?! The storyline - KPOP and time travel - different and refreshing! And I KNEW, I just knew it was going to be hilarious with Yoon ShiYoon and Cha TaeHyun in the main roles. But about half way in, I realized this was a burning train heading towards a bridge over a canyon where tracks have been blown to pieces and the brakes don't work. Simply put, it did not end well.
The most glaring problem is quite common and a major reason I favor thriller/suspense/crime kdramas over romcom/sitcom dramas - I have noticed that romcom writers focus a little too much on the comedy and romance and not enough on story development or clean (SENSICAL) end. Simply put, Hit the Top lacked direction and had too many underdeveloped, unnecessary storylines. There was a strong beginning with distinct, relatable goals that viewers could be invested in but ending was tepid, uninteresting, and unimaginative. A singer whose time in the spotlight was cut short and trying to relive former glory; an experienced manager trying to revive a dying business with a passion and charm to change an industry for the better; a talented son who hid his dreams because of his father's disapproval and his two equally talented and aspiring best friend also overcoming obstacles in the attempt for glory; and the guy from the past, who essentially ruined their lives inadvertently, dropped in the future - a strange world where he must reckon with his character and fix the mistakes of his past self. Also there was mystery! Where did the money go? Where did he disappear to in 1994? It was so good and interesting in the beginning, it is frustrating to know how it ends!
All of it fell flat when the show shifted focus to this strange father-son-girl best friend love triangle which had me asking strange questions like if it is appropriate to be interested in your son's best friend, who he also has a crush on, if you are you from the past so you are actually around the same age but still your his father so technically you are about 20 years older but should he be dating anyway he is an idol-in-training bu ... AYYYYYY JJINJA SHIRO!!!!
I am still racking my brain, trying to understand the thought process behind how the screenwriter turned so many storylines ... aniyo ... ALL of the storylines bad. What was the purpose of the supporting cast if you were going to abandon them half way in? Why did you switch the 1st/2nd male/female romance leads to this strange love triangle? Like, the 1st male/female lead is SUPPOSED to be JiHoon and WooSeung and the 2nd male/female lead SHOULD HAVE BEEN Do HyeRi and MJ. Why did you set it up and then scatter it? (like MJ did with the puzzle art, ha!... sorry, my humor is as equally dry as MJ's LOL!) And MJ?? I will say that Cha EunWoo did carry this character and I love him for that but that does not negate that he literally terrorized WooSeung for what?? And I still don't get why he blocked JiHoon from debuting? Such an interesting action that is never addressed. OMG, and I just remembered he came to the rooftop at the end of that one episode and then ... NOTHING! Never addressed, never visited again, like it never happened. Why build such grandiose problems and then have such simple solutions? For example, we literally watched Drill bomb his monthly performance, get kicked out of the company, at his wit's end working part-time and hiding from his best friend, and he just ... gets over it???? Why such lackluster villainy? They failed so miserably at setting Park YeongJae and the chairwoman as the bad guys that every win felt ... eehh, mild. Also, I enjoyed the grandfather's presence very much but that does not change the fact that his story did nothing, and I mean absolutely NOTHING, to drive the primary storyline. Like... I am assuming the main plot was supposed to be the entertainment industry is cutthroat and this person from the past has come to the future to fix his mistakes and help those that should have been great reach greatness. So what does the retired president of a dying agency having dementia have to do with the overall plot other than sprinkle sad, touching moments throughout the series? And this grand paragraph is just the surface of all that went wrong. I am still having flashbacks of the trivial continuity issues (if you see/saw it, you know what I mean, there were several).
I have to say I felt like Park Kyung Sun in "The Fiery Priest" - STREEEEESSSSSSSSSS!
It really hurt my spirit to finish this show because it's screenwriting 101 and they really missed the mark on what could have been a great romcom, sitcom, whatever it was trying to be.
One thing I will give DA BONG to is its comedic timing and predictability. Jokes landed where they were supposed to land and certain scenes had me going "oh no please don't tell me the wrote it in, don't do it, oh please... lol they did ha!" (i.e. when Da Bong fell through the roof on his own memorial altar - now THAT was comedy!) They relied heavily on tropes and cliches, either subverting them (i.e. the scene when he leaves the hospital and someone magically appears beside him to explain how he came to the future but is actually talking on the phone, ha!) or holding on to them dearly (i.e. the love triangle. It was fairly easy to spot the switch from the HyeRi-JiHoon-WooSeung-MJ to JiHoon-WooSeung-DoBong and also who would end up with who early on. Like COME ON, the sudden rain/umbrella trick, "helping" the other male lead get the girl he has been crushing on for ages, the adamant disapproval/hatred towards the female lead, ALL very obvious and truly tiring to see).
I truly feel it was a waste of the time and attention I invested. Reflecting on it, it really should have been written so much differently. Maybe it is just me but I think HyeRi, JiHoon, WooSeung, and MJ should have been the leads, focused on them plus Drill trying to resolve their respective problems, DoBong and GwangJae are the strong comedic support who help rectify the mistakes of the past and give the kids the momentum they need to succeed, BoHee's career revival actually HAPPENS, and then MalSook and haraboji have the cute sparks of wisdom/enlightenment moments. SEE! I have reduced the trillion storylines to three (and we would get more EunWoo-MinJae scenes. My eyes are already watery thinking about what we lost, disrespectful).
Thank goodness it's a pandemic and I am on vacation so I had nothing better to do or I would be even more bitter than I am now.
The most glaring problem is quite common and a major reason I favor thriller/suspense/crime kdramas over romcom/sitcom dramas - I have noticed that romcom writers focus a little too much on the comedy and romance and not enough on story development or clean (SENSICAL) end. Simply put, Hit the Top lacked direction and had too many underdeveloped, unnecessary storylines. There was a strong beginning with distinct, relatable goals that viewers could be invested in but ending was tepid, uninteresting, and unimaginative. A singer whose time in the spotlight was cut short and trying to relive former glory; an experienced manager trying to revive a dying business with a passion and charm to change an industry for the better; a talented son who hid his dreams because of his father's disapproval and his two equally talented and aspiring best friend also overcoming obstacles in the attempt for glory; and the guy from the past, who essentially ruined their lives inadvertently, dropped in the future - a strange world where he must reckon with his character and fix the mistakes of his past self. Also there was mystery! Where did the money go? Where did he disappear to in 1994? It was so good and interesting in the beginning, it is frustrating to know how it ends!
All of it fell flat when the show shifted focus to this strange father-son-girl best friend love triangle which had me asking strange questions like if it is appropriate to be interested in your son's best friend, who he also has a crush on, if you are you from the past so you are actually around the same age but still your his father so technically you are about 20 years older but should he be dating anyway he is an idol-in-training bu ... AYYYYYY JJINJA SHIRO!!!!
I am still racking my brain, trying to understand the thought process behind how the screenwriter turned so many storylines ... aniyo ... ALL of the storylines bad. What was the purpose of the supporting cast if you were going to abandon them half way in? Why did you switch the 1st/2nd male/female romance leads to this strange love triangle? Like, the 1st male/female lead is SUPPOSED to be JiHoon and WooSeung and the 2nd male/female lead SHOULD HAVE BEEN Do HyeRi and MJ. Why did you set it up and then scatter it? (like MJ did with the puzzle art, ha!... sorry, my humor is as equally dry as MJ's LOL!) And MJ?? I will say that Cha EunWoo did carry this character and I love him for that but that does not negate that he literally terrorized WooSeung for what?? And I still don't get why he blocked JiHoon from debuting? Such an interesting action that is never addressed. OMG, and I just remembered he came to the rooftop at the end of that one episode and then ... NOTHING! Never addressed, never visited again, like it never happened. Why build such grandiose problems and then have such simple solutions? For example, we literally watched Drill bomb his monthly performance, get kicked out of the company, at his wit's end working part-time and hiding from his best friend, and he just ... gets over it???? Why such lackluster villainy? They failed so miserably at setting Park YeongJae and the chairwoman as the bad guys that every win felt ... eehh, mild. Also, I enjoyed the grandfather's presence very much but that does not change the fact that his story did nothing, and I mean absolutely NOTHING, to drive the primary storyline. Like... I am assuming the main plot was supposed to be the entertainment industry is cutthroat and this person from the past has come to the future to fix his mistakes and help those that should have been great reach greatness. So what does the retired president of a dying agency having dementia have to do with the overall plot other than sprinkle sad, touching moments throughout the series? And this grand paragraph is just the surface of all that went wrong. I am still having flashbacks of the trivial continuity issues (if you see/saw it, you know what I mean, there were several).
I have to say I felt like Park Kyung Sun in "The Fiery Priest" - STREEEEESSSSSSSSSS!
It really hurt my spirit to finish this show because it's screenwriting 101 and they really missed the mark on what could have been a great romcom, sitcom, whatever it was trying to be.
One thing I will give DA BONG to is its comedic timing and predictability. Jokes landed where they were supposed to land and certain scenes had me going "oh no please don't tell me the wrote it in, don't do it, oh please... lol they did ha!" (i.e. when Da Bong fell through the roof on his own memorial altar - now THAT was comedy!) They relied heavily on tropes and cliches, either subverting them (i.e. the scene when he leaves the hospital and someone magically appears beside him to explain how he came to the future but is actually talking on the phone, ha!) or holding on to them dearly (i.e. the love triangle. It was fairly easy to spot the switch from the HyeRi-JiHoon-WooSeung-MJ to JiHoon-WooSeung-DoBong and also who would end up with who early on. Like COME ON, the sudden rain/umbrella trick, "helping" the other male lead get the girl he has been crushing on for ages, the adamant disapproval/hatred towards the female lead, ALL very obvious and truly tiring to see).
I truly feel it was a waste of the time and attention I invested. Reflecting on it, it really should have been written so much differently. Maybe it is just me but I think HyeRi, JiHoon, WooSeung, and MJ should have been the leads, focused on them plus Drill trying to resolve their respective problems, DoBong and GwangJae are the strong comedic support who help rectify the mistakes of the past and give the kids the momentum they need to succeed, BoHee's career revival actually HAPPENS, and then MalSook and haraboji have the cute sparks of wisdom/enlightenment moments. SEE! I have reduced the trillion storylines to three (and we would get more EunWoo-MinJae scenes. My eyes are already watery thinking about what we lost, disrespectful).
Thank goodness it's a pandemic and I am on vacation so I had nothing better to do or I would be even more bitter than I am now.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?