Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Lame and boring
You may see my rating too harsh for the dramaBut really it destroyed my beautiful expectations about it
This drama had a happy ending but as usual they should leave each other first
It began for couple of episodes boring and slow till the limit I thought many times to drop it
Then I decided to continue and I found it nice, emotional with cute slow romance reminds me with old slow pace dramas
Then Down the hill
boring again and illogical events
and the story began to have lots of flaws
First of all I liked every side story EXCEPT both main leads , mother and aunt
The ML , FL's Mom and aunt had a dead face expression
Solid as rock
Emotionless family
Even if the ML had an isolated character, after falling in love and being changed , I hoped to see more changes in his attitude and face expression but that doesn't happen
The FL was toooooooo selfish for me
always focused on herself
Her feelings
Her circumstances
Her situation
No excuses for others
While the crime was happening there should be a black box in the car videoing what happened
Because the aunt killed the father under the pressure of being terrified
She wasn't in her conscious
And when she confessed for her niece
She should tell her the whole story in detail
Which I think she already did it in her book
So the FL's reaction was extremely weird
I know she must be sad on her father
But giving excuse at the same time for her aunt especially the FL already said she hated her dad
Even after telling the ML she loved him
She left him sooooo easily with a cold smile telling him wish you great life and to continue be the same warm person
because she can't see her aunt any more
Ignoring his Feelings totally
What annoyed me like hell
That she forgiven her aunt and back to town to see her, but didn't bother herself to call the man whom she told him once I love you
She gave me the feeling she left the country because of him
She acted as if she remembered her love for him only when she saw him coincidentally again
Except that she can continue her stupid life easily without him
I think that's definitely because she guaranteed his love
I thought she was going to encourage him to write and be a big writer but no
Doesn't also happen
The writer focused on misery
Torturing themselves and how to be sad and ungrateful for all what you had because you lost one important thing from many important others
And what was the worst ever
The background music
For the first time Background tracks made me nervous and felt annoyed so much
The best part for me was what the FL's friend told her at ep. 15 when she took her in her house
I dislike this drama really
The end was stupid and for the first time I wished the ML refused to get back to her
Sad about my gigas and time
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
tis the damn season
Seo Kang joon's best drama for me, he played that introverted character with trauma very well, the story is the warm and cold same time and this is the best thing about drama, the book club part was so cute and I want to read all book they mentioned, the last episode was good but 15 was bad I really hate fl that episode and they ruined her all image in 1 episode, whenever I rw this drama I always skipped that episode, overall best drama!Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
It‘s my second drama with Park Min Young, I really love her acting, she is becoming one of my favorite korean actresses.
Seo Kang Joon I saw for the first time and I feel a bit in love with him. I adored him in this role and can't wait to see him in many other dramas.
The chemistry was also great.
I espcially loved the book club scenes and all the side characters were likable and had enough depth so you care for them and want to know how there stories goes.
If you like slow healing dramas this one is the perfect one!
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
The Perfect Winter's Day Healing Drama
If there's one thing you should know about me going into this drama review, it's that:a) one of my most listened to songs of 2021 was from Chung Joon Han's score for this drama (Good Night Irene)
b) I have a 'Bookstore Journal' google doc where I typed up all of Eun Seob's blog posts from the show, to look at when ever I need a pick-me-up.
Now that my clear adoration for this little show is established, I have to say: unfortunately, this is not a perfect drama. Eun Seob's trauma plot line seemingly comes out of nowhere and is neatly resolved in a handful of episodes (seriously, what happened to that uncle?). Don't get me started on the ep 16 separation (which I will go into in more depth in a sec). Mok Hae Won's tragedy obviously takes up a larger portion of the plot, and I think the writers did a good job of letting the story unfold naturally without dragging it out for too long or condensing it too much. The main performances are great; Seo Kang Joon is adorable as the quietly-lovestruck Eun Seob, but his more emotional scenes really pack a punch. I thought the complex relationship between the three Mok/Shim women was very interesting to watch, carried by great performances.
I adore the little sequences of life in the town, the book club meetings, the shots of the landscape. The romance is lovely to watch, and as I mentioned before I really do love Eun Seob's little blog posts included at the end of each episode - so much so that I actually wish they'd included it more within the runtime itself, allow us to see a bit more of ES's innermost thoughts.
Now to the big booboo in my view: the eleventh-hour separation. We all know Kdramas love a good episode 16 separation when they've run out of plot; unfortunately, WTWIF is no difference. It is beyond frustrating to see this relationship you've been earnestly following for 15 episodes nearly implode because 1) MHW couldn't have like... given him a call or two from Seoul? And 2) Eun Seob, whose entire character arc relied on him being a traumatised guy slowly learning to open up to people and take ownership over his own voice, didn't even try to fight for the relationship when MHW left, or when she came back. The scenes of her being back in town without contacting him, and him virtually ignoring her were painful beyond belief, and made me feel like the entire development of the relationship over the series was for nought. Argh.
Ok. Breathe. Rant over. Despite its flaws, this show is a gorgeous breath of fresh, winter air. Watch it with a blanket and a cup of tea, let the pure ~vibes~ wash over you. And maybe skip most of the final episode.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Like a warm hug
Add this to the list of dramas that make me want to move to the countryside and run a little bookstore.I loved almost everything about this drama. The yearning of the main couple is impeccable, the warmth of the bookstore and the town was so comforting, and I grew to love all the side characters as well, from the family members to the book club. The show handles darker and heavier topics of domestic violence and familial issues relatively well.
With that being said, this drama still fell victim to the episode 15 curse. The last minute separation trope is one of my least favorite plot devices of all time and this drama is an example of why. The plot started falling apart with the characters' (particularly the female lead's) decision-making around those heavier topics, and the time jump felt underdeveloped and unnecessary.
Still, this was an amazing watch; I know some people complained that it was too slow but it was perfect for me. It's one of the dramas you watch wrapped up in a blanket with a cup of hot tea, and you just let it warm you up.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
Most of all, it's calm
I'm writing a review exclusively because I can't get over the fact that a partner (or any other person) reading a private diary is framed as cute. It's not cute, it's a violation of privacy. Being someone's partner doesn't give you the right to their privacy.Other than that it was a drama that transmitted a lot of calm despite all the traumatic events it dealt with.
The supporting cast was excellent and without them, this drama would be reduced to almost nothing since I don't find the main characters remarkable or important enough to the action. To me, it would make more sense if the drama was set from the aunt's point of view.
There are some things in life that can never be amended. Not even time can do that. Time can't amend treason or violence. I don't understand the love for a physically abusive parent and it doesn't make a difference who stepped on the gas pedal. It was self-defence from someone who was threatening their lives and had already made their lives miserable for so many years. I do see a reason for the aunt's actions, she was hit too and her sister's and her life were in danger. It's very logical to me. Even if the lead's father had never hit the aunt, she had every right to protect her sister. Her sister's bruises hurt her as well, it's surprising to see that the mother's bruises didn't hurt the daughter. Her loving father is the same person that tried to kill her mother and her aunt and that's not something you can separate from that person, it's the same father.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Le plaisir de la vie dans un village de motagne en hiver, plus Seo Kang Jeon...
Dans l’ensemble, j’ai bien aimé ce drama, pour trois raisons principales :1 - le fait que nous soyons dans la campagne, dans la montagne et la neige en hiver, ce qui nous change des ruelles de Séoul et des maison sur les toits habituelles des héros !
2 - La deuxième raison c’est l’atmosphère bon enfant et les relations chaleureuses des gens du village, particulièrement les séances du club de lecture, et les évènements populaires organisés par Lee Kang Wu, brillant élève qui a préféré revenir travailler dans sa ville natale pour l’animer !
3 - La troisième, et non la moindre, c’est la présence de Seo Kang Joon, qui m’avait fortement impressionnée dans « Watcher » et grâce à qui je vais retenter « cheese in the trap » !
Ce drama partait pour être du genre de ceux que j’aime tout particulièrement : une société de gens simples, des histoires cachées qui se révèlent, une jolie romance pas bête, des personnages attachants…
Il y avait tout ça, mais il y avait aussi un scénario bancal et confus qui m’a laissée sur ma faim, ouvrant des perspectives et les laissant en plan, sans conclusion (comme le coup de l’arrivée de l’oncle du héros, dont on pense qu’elle va provoquer quelque chose d’important, et qui tourne court…) La scénariste en est à son premier drama, j’espère qu’elle va progresser parce qu’il y avait beaucoup de jolies choses en germe dans cette histoire, mais qui n’ont pas été développées.
Et pour finir j’ai eu beaucoup de mal avec Park Min Young !! C’est elle qui interprétait le personnage adolescent et adulte en même temps, et franchement, en gamine de 17 ans, elle n’était pas crédible ! Son visage est bien changé, et surtout son regard souvent écarquillé m’a souvent gênée. Et je n’aime pas du tout son jeu, qui sonne souvent faux… Quelle différence avec son interprétation de SKKS ou de Healer !!! Bon, je me suis consolée avec Seo Gang Joon, parfait, lui ! Parfait de chez parfait ! Il en dit plus dans un regard que dans 10 lignes de dialogue !
Donc mon impression générale est mitigée : j’aurais voulu l’adorer, parce qu’il y a tout ce que j’aime : quelques très belles scènes avec des personnages originaux (la mère, la tante, ) la liaison constante entre le passé et le présent qui s’entremêlent en découvrant peu à peu les secrets cachés, l’évolution des deux héros sortant de l’ombre vers la lumière…Mais le scénario a de grosses faiblesses et Park Min Young m’a gênée tout du long !
Mais si vous l’aimez et l’admirez, alors c’est pour vous !
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
When the Weather Is Whine
I liked the stories involving the female lead, her mother and her aunt, they kept you anticipating for more. However, the other side plots were really not that interesting to follow and ended up being just a white noise. From reading the synopsis and watching its earlier parts, we got to know what the female was going through and why she moved away from the city. Clearly, she had issues she needed to work on, however, despite her issues with trusting people and being hurt by others, her romance went against her character. She had a very easy and quick romance with minimum communication for a drama that meant to be driven by dialogue. She started a relationship in a short period of time before scratching the surface of her issues. It would've been much better to replace the romance with the people of her town, it would have had created a much better environment to work on her issues. In fact, the resolution and progress on her issues ended up being half-hearted, not much was accomplished by the end. On another note, I didn't like that the characters past stories were based in high-school, there was a gap that couldn't be translated to their adulthood life. If they were to switch the past events and have it be based in university for example, I think that would create a better connection, relatability and meaning to their adulthood issues.Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Deze recentie kan spoilers bevatten
i have complicated feelings towards this drama
for me the only good thing about this drama is eunsil and jangho and the beautiful place where they shot the drama.trigger warning : domestic abuse
i hated two things about this drama.
one is the ml's behaviour at the very first few episodes. like why cant he just say something?? its not like i wanted him to pour his heart out all at once because i understand that he had a rough life and everybody processes their trauma differently but he can atleast give a simple reason for his actions or i dont know complete one freaking sentence. he was extremely frustrating to watch at the start of the story.
the second one is way more infuriating. as someone who has an abusive father like haewon, i cannot understand how could she get seriously mad with her mom and aunt but not with her criminal of a father. i would be very happy for my mom if she can get her freedom, not that i want her to commit murder or something but the point is i will never blame her if she does something to protect herself and i would never side and pity an abusive man.
and as if those werent stressful enough, kim boyeong gave me head-splitting headaches. she was extremely annoying and arrogant. she completely disregards haewon's feelings. she's the perfect example of a character who wants to be a victim so bad up until the very end she was very prideful and even tried to gaslight haewon into thinking that she hurt her more and that she deserved a second chance. kim boyeong made haewon's highschool life miserable but she still thinks she doesnt deserve how haewon treated her after.
also, they didnt explain why eunseop was calling haewon "irene" until the very end??! what the hell was that all about??
it took me 3 or probably 4 times until i was finally able to finish watching this drama. i did consider completely dropping it after haewon started getting mad at her mom and aunt for protecting themselves against her abusive father. it was a very slow and quiet drama at first. it was like reading a book. there werent a lot of rousing dialogues. most of the time the characters just convey their feelings through their eyes or through the books they read and/or share to each other. i needed to be in a particular mood to watch this drama. for some reason i only craved to watch this when it was raining outside or when the day feels very gloomy and cold. another thing i found entertaining besides eunsil and jangho's story is haewon's mom and aunt. the casting director knew what they were doing, like the actresses can actually pass as sisters even in real life. this drama also made me realize that you shouldnt really judge someone based on their looks especially when it comes to romantic relationships. like i was so confused when the flashbacks of haewon's mom and dad started because i cannot believe that kid would end up abusing haewon's mom. it was very disturbing to me.
surprisingly, i also liked oh yeong woo. normally when there is already an established love interest for the fl i dont really like when they bring out an ex or just someone from the past who has/had feelings for the fl/ml but oh yeongwoo kind of made it work for me.
anyways, the drama was fine but if i can go back to the past i think i wouldnt try this much just to finish watching it.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
Books and emotions
This is a labor of love! I advise to watch it during the winter months. Poor yourself some red wine, warm sake or tea and crawl under a blamket. Don't be surprised if you binge it in a few days.It's not an easy story but a series of stories about regret, jealousy, loneliness and yes alo love.
Set around a book shop in a small village with a loveble cast of extras. It watches like a Murakami novel. It sort of passes you by and at the end of it you are left alone having had the privilage of being part of their lives for a short while.
Park min Young is cute (as always) but I had the most fun watching Kim Hwan Hee. She plays a bright, funny character.
Watch it on Viki Rakuten.
Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
I really loved this drama because ,it felt warm
this is the perfect drama for romance with a little bit of tragedy and warmth in every scene ,I felt happy while i watched it ,the acting was great and the story itself even better ,this drama portrayed a lot of emotions I related to and a lot of beautiful scenes , as an usual cold person I could relate so much to this drama, I have to admit that at first I thought it was boring but now I've totally changed my mind, I hope people will see how beautiful this drama is and feel warm while watching it ,just like how I felt, I loved it. :)Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
My Winter Comfort Watch
I have developed a keen sense for when a drama really is a breath of fresh air, icy cool fresh air in this case. Within the first few minutes of this show, I automatically knew I was going to love it. The whole show felt like cashmere sweaters, old books, chai lattes, and a fireplace filled with peace. I wondered at first what was it about this drama that made me feel this calmness? I shortly found out that it was because of the sound, the silence. They did a really good job of not oversaturating every scene with some repetitive ballad of romance. It was simple and sweet, the natural ambiance of that town. This is such a rare find in dramas for it to be so fuzzy and the couple together they really have great chemistry. For me personally, this drama is very underrated and it is my favorite. I know I can just sit and not worry about there being some crazy car crash or unbelievable situation. The story is too good for that and it really is well written when it comes to relationships and friendships; if anything I feel the friendship plays a bigger role in the title. I definitely recommend this show for when you feel emotionally exhausted from real life, this one will put you at ease. This drama is engraved in my calendar as my yearly winter comfort watch. Can I also get a pair of the cool aunts' sunglasses?Vond je deze recentie nuttig?
